Subject: Pacific Northwest Beaver operations.
From: rotaryeng
Date: 8/23/2014, 3:25 PM
To: AA-1-Me


Hi Paul, Pacific Northwest, Coal Harbour BC, Canada. Here are
some pics of AirCab,s aircraft and operations base.

http://www.flickriver.com/photos/tags/aircab/interesting/

Steve Carlisle

Somebody should certify a turbo 3 rotor with an AC Carb and
AC magnetos. Would make a great power plant for a Beaver.
AC fuel injection could also be used. Makes certification
much easier. Mistral stumbled in part because they tried
to certify EFI. The FAA is not fond of EFI.

Paul Lamar


Paul, this note involves experimental alternative engines, but not
rotary, you may find it interesting. Sealand Aviation, the
maintenance facility that looks after the AirCab fleet has partnered
with Trace to development the next generation power for the old
Beaver. Here is a link to that company and what they build,
http://www.traceengines.com/aircraft-kits

Steve Carlisle



That looks like the Thunder/Orenda Chevy big block based engine. Name
changed.
Last time I checked they were over $100,000 US with a TBO of only 1200
hours.

Here is a history of that engine.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/DS-smith-art.pdf

Paul Lamar

Paul, it could well be that design you speak of, it seems now according
to their website, TBO is 2000 Hours. Seems like many cost advantages
compared to turbine, and of course in the near future no rebuilding of
the radials.


Steve Carlisle

The price doubled to $200,000 :)

They don't actually claim 2000 hour FAA TBO.  They try to imply 2000 hours.

26 gallons an hour is only 162 pounds per hour.
At a BSFC of .5 that is only 310 HP.
Giving them the benefit of the doubt at a BSFC of .45 that is only 360HP.
Aircraft Turbo engines usually run full rich at .6 BSFC
In that case it is only  270 HP :)

That web site does not pass the lie detector test :)

Here is my review of the mag article.

Smithsonian Air & Space magazine article "Power Struggle" by Don
Sherman, January 1997, page 72. Excellent ten page  article (with
many pictures) about auto engines in airplanes. A brief history of
all auto engines in airplanes and a more detailed history of the
twenty year, twenty million dollar  development of the Chevy V8
based, all aluminum Orenda liquid cooled aircraft engine. At this
time (Jan 1997) and well after the article was written the engine
failed its FAA 150 hour full power certification test due to a
crankshaft problem after 20 years of very expensive development.
It was finally certified in 1998 by Transport Canada.

Extensive changes have been made to the basic Chevy big block engine
including a parallel cooling system with dual coolant pumps as
opposed to the serial cooling system with single pump as typically
found in automotive engines. Parallel cooling systems were
considered to be essential in the 1920's on liquid cooled aircraft
engines.

Engine length is almost everything to a car designer. Engine cooling
compromises are made by simezing the cylinder walls in automotive
engines. Crankshaft life at high continuous power is compromised by
shortening the length, leaving too little room for adequate size
journal fillet radii. In my opinion this engine will not be
successful until it is re-designed from a clean sheet of paper to be
a real aircraft engine. If that happens they might as well go to a
horizontal opposed configuration for lighter weight.
V and in-line engines try to shove the crank shaft out the bottom
of the block. In horizontal opposed aircraft engines these loads are taken
by long high strength steel bolts from side to side.

Orenda tried moving the project to Nova Scotia
and injecting another 32 million dollars of mostly Canadian
government money. They are also attempting to market the engine to
the homebuilt market. I don't expect many takers at over $100K per engine.

Recently Lancair gave up after spending a lot of money installing
the engine in a special airplane called the Lancair Tigress.
The engine and the Tigress were donated to the EAA museum as
a tax write off.

The Orenda company is now bankrupt.

Apparently Trace bought the project.

BTW if your going to certify a 600 HP rotary you might as well
make it a 4 rotor as you will have to make all the parts anyway.
The FAA requires a paper trail from the mine to the air.

Paul Lamar



The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
 ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
 You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
 Copyright 1998-2014 All world wide rights reserved.