Subject: P-port or not to P-Port
From: "rotaryeng@earthlink.net" <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Date: 3/21/2015, 11:43 AM
To: AA-1-Me



   Hi Paul,

   Having read your website,

   There are a number of WHATIF flies buzzing around my head if you would be
   kind enough to swat them for me for a good night sleep.

   1. "It takes HP to suck the combustion air into the engine" .

   Does that mean you simply allow more air to go to the combustion chamber
   with no MORE EXTRA in FUEL resulting in greater output HP ?

   1a) By Output Horsepower my understand is the flywheel will achieve 1000rpm
   in less time and the flywheel will overcome friction/resistance using same
   amount of fuel.

   2. If my above assumption of more air no extra fuel is correct then an ECU
   like Megasquirt simply continues to squirt (using direct injection) same
   amount of fuel into the combustion chamber and firing the spark at the
   appropriate time ?


   3. To harness the extra Horse Power and rev up the engine you suggested
   using the new side throttle system with p-port. Does that mean the using
   VERNIER CONTROL Is that the new throttle cable. But I am wondering there
   must be some sensor which tells the ECU as you pull the cable to allow more
   air fuel into the combustion before the usual sparking ?


   4. As far the Megasquirt is concerned should it continue to behave same
   usual

   even if the engine wasn't p-ported with reference to amount of fuel to
   squirt and then spark.


   5. If my aircraft has an all in weight of 450kg including engine,pilot,
   wallet . I have fuel tank of say 80 litres. I want the fuel to last as
   long as possible which engine should I use 13b , 13b P-port, 13b Turbo ,
   16b , 16b P-port , 16b Turbo , 13b Turbo Compound or another option ?


   Regards

   Zahid Rahman


   1. The fuel air ratio must be maintained. It all has to do with BSFC.
   Brake Specific Fuel Consumption.
     This is the weight of fuel burned per HP out of the engine. Google
   BSFC.


   1a. Yes the engine will accelerate faster but HP is not the only factor.
   Rotating inertia is a major factor.

   2. Mega Squirt maintains the correct fuel air ratio.

   3. A slide throttle reduces in internal aerodynamic drag of the intake
   system.

   4. Same answer as 2. The sensor is either a mass airflow sensor or
   simply the intake manifold
    pressure and  air temperature.

   5. For best BSFC use a turbo compound RX8 engine. Soon to be available
   from Mazda.
    May not be P-port so a lower BFSC would be possible with a turbo
   compound P-port.

   Paul Lamar


    When is it appropriate to use reduction ratios 2.85 and when should
   one use 3.17.

    The reverse rotation also available with Ford of 2.17:1 and 1.85:1
   , is it used with piston engines because they turn in the opposite
   direction to the rotary.

    Zahid Rahman

    HP is RPM times torque.

    Most aircraft piston engines turn in the same direction as the rotary.

    Are you a pilot?

    Paul Lamar



   Not yet. I going to build  my own light aircraft as a hobby. I asked the
   question because I thought
   it said on your website the rotary engine turn in opposite direction and
   uses 2.17 reduction ratio.

   Zahid Rahman

   The Mazda engine rotates the same direction as most AC engines rotate.

   Paul Lamar

   Hi Zahid,
   I am building an LSA aircraft, I am using a single rotor 13b sideported,
   you will probably want to use the alloy side plates from Racing Beat in the
   US. The alloy plates will save a considerable amount of weight. At 450Kgs
   if you are a two seat aircraft you will want to be fairly weight conscious.
   If you use a single rotor, side porting would seem the way to go. You will
   have to find someone to machine the e shaft as they are not available off
   the shelf. You should have no difficulty in producing 120Hp The less Hp you
   require the less fuel you will burn. Large savings in fuel burn can be
   achieved by building the right plane for your needs. In the LSA Field there
   are some very efficient aircraft around.
   Andrew. CampBell

   A side port single rotor is definitely not the way to go.

   Paul Lamar

   Zahid Rahman




   I am definitely going to build 450 kg weight limit two seat aircraft.
   I don't know if Single Rotor side port is the way to go or not.
   however you can get the e-shaft off the  shelf.
   http://atkinsrotary.com/store/One-Rotor-Eccentric-Shaft.html <http://atkinsrotary.com/store/One-Rotor-Eccentric-Shaft.html>
   http://atkinsrotary.com/store/One-Rotor-Rotating-Assembly- <http://atkinsrotary.com/store/One-Rotor-Rotating-Assembly->
   Shaft-Rotor-Counterweights-Balancing-Service.html

   Zahid Rahman

   Single rotor P port IS the way to go :-)
   Richard Sohn <res12@fairpoint.net <mailto:res12@fairpoint.net>>


   Sixteen years  ago Dave Atkins wife told me I was not to mention their name
   :-)
   I would send this to them but their email address is not on their web site
   :-)

   Paul Lamar



   Hi Richard
   Have you sorted out all the teething problems.
   How close is  your fuel consumption  to 10-13  litres per hour.

   The one problem with Atkins e-shaft is that it is nearly same price as a
   brand new Aluminium engine with same HP


   Zahid Rahman

   Fuel consumption is directly related to HP.
   What HP are you talking about?
  Full power? 70% of full power? What?

   Paul

The mistake I am trying avoid in choosing the best engine for 450 kg weight limit two seat aircraft is this.

The Mercedes  ML 270  has worse fuel economy than the ML 320 because the 2.7 engine is under powered  for the weight of car.

 Zahid Rahman

That is a ridiculous comparisons. There are probably 100 or more uncontrolled variables in that comparison.
Speed acceleration, weight, rolling drag, aero drag, to name just a few.
What stupid car magazine printed that?


Full power? 70% of full power? What?
Full power? 70% of full power? What?
Full power? 70% of full power? What?

Paul Lamar

     The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
   ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
   You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
   Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.