It amazes me what people will put up with to burn kerosene. .82
lb/(hp-hr) and they talk like its the greatest thing since sliced
bread. 19 gph! compared to 11.5 running lean with the IO-540.
The world really really needs a heavy-fuel-burning rotary! And
this article - is Amy smart enough to realize that if the CG
difference makes the plane feel so much different than her IO-540
RV-10, it might mean there could be an aft CG issue with 4 people
and bags? Might that be something to discuss in a flight review
article?
David Bonorden
I would never buy one. Diesel fumes stink and they are
carcinogenic. Packard figured that out in 1930"s. The power to
weight ratio sucks.
Diesel should only be used in trucks and ships. The only reason it
is popular in European cars is the tax is a dollar a gallon less.
If they taxed it as high as gasoline ($7 or$ 8 gallon) it would
seriously affect the European economy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
C172 gasoline verses C172 diesel data from the Cessna web site.
Diesel fuel is a pound heavier than gasoline. Gas is six pounds
per gallon and diesel is 7 pounds per gallon.
44.6 gallons of diesel weighs 312 pounds of fuel.
Max useful load on a Diesel C172 is 742 pounds. Subtract the full
fuel weight and you get 430 pounds. Range is 588 nm. 85% power is
132 HP. Cruise speed at 85% power is 118 kts or 5 hours.
8.9 gallons an hour or 62.5 pounds per hour. BSFC is therefore
.47. Not a lot different than a fully leaned Mazda rotary. And
typical for a diesel engine running near full power.
How can this be? Everybody knows that diesel cars get much better
mileage than gasoline powered cars. The fact is diesel engines
running near full power are not much better than gasoline engines
based on a HP per pound of fuel burned. See the attached chart.
A leaned Mazda rotary at 132 HP would be about the same BSFC but
the gallons per hour would be higher at 62.5/6 or 10.4 gallons per
hour.
A turbo compound rotary on the other hand would be down in the
below .4 range or about the same as a truck diesel running at 50%
power.
------------------------------------------------------ The numbers
for a stock Lycoming powered C172 are:
56 gallons of gasoline weighs 336 pounds of fuel. Max useful load
is 758 pounds. Subtract the full fuel weight and you get 422
pounds. Range is 580 nm. 80% power is 128 HP. Cruise speed at 80%
power is 122 Kts or 4.8 hours.
Four kts faster than the diesel.
11.8 gallons an hour or 69.6 pounds per hour. BSFC is therefore
.54 which is a typical for a Lycoming rich of peak.
It would take a long time to pay for the extra $15,000 you will
pay for a diesel powered Cessna 172.
Not to mention you are required to throw the diesel away at 1200
hours if it does not pass detailed inspection. No overhaul allowed.
If it does pass 1200 hour detailed inspection you are required to
throw it away at 2400 hours. No exceptions.
At 100 hours a year that is 24 years. At that point the Mercedes A
class diesel engine will probably no longer be available so the
air plane, in theory, will be worthless. One would have to replace
the engine now certified in the Mercedes A class diesel powered
Cessna 172 with some other engine and obtain an FAA one time STC.
I don't see it.
Do you want to tow or do you want to go?
Paul Lamar
A hobbyist doubt: if the density of Diesel fuel, the weight per
volume, is higher: would this mean that in a liter of Diesel fuel
there are more Carbon and Hydrogen molecules to be burnt, and thus,
the power density of fuel is better, a liter of Diesel yields more
heat when burnt, this adding to explain the better SFC of Diesels
in terms of gr/kW/hr, besides the better thermal efficiency from the
much higher Compression Ratio, or this was taken into account in
Diesel vs Gasoline SFC figures?
I've learned from this e-mail about the meaning of 'Thermal load'
inside an Internal Combustion Engine, HP per surface of combustion
chamber, and MEP, I remembered having read about the worries of the
early Air-Cooled Wankel Engine designers about increasing CR and
Power, because of the dangers of thermal load (on bearings and
shafts?), and on the lubricating oil film, but the chart you added
indicates an extremely low thermal load for the only RCE on it, a
Mistral. Is this because of the poor MEP of Wankel, or for other
reasons?
The high surface to volume ratio of Wankel RCE combustion chamber
was blamed for the improvable fuel economy, but the surface/volume
ratio in the time of top compression may not be the same during the
process of expansion, where the working chamber volume increases,
both in the irregular shaped Wankel and in the classical cylinder.
How does the plot of surface/volume ratio changes from 'TDC' to 'BDC'
compare in a Wankel versus a reciprocating engine? Somebody to
forward here a chart about this? Is there a safe way, safe for the
lubricating oil film, the bearings, and the shaft, for increasing the
housing and/or Rotor working surface temperatures, a condition that
was shown improving fuel economy and cleanliness of exhaust gases?
Some tested an Iron housing, with improved results in SFC and exhaust
gases over Aluminum, but I've read nothing about differences in
thermal dilatation between housing and rotor when both are made of
iron, and if this makes possible having the engine seized when
overheated. Thanks have a nice season. Best regards. Salut † Jose
Gros-Aymerich Madrid, Spain
PS: the Napier was a Single Sleeve-Valve. 2-Stroke, compression
ignition engine, Harry Ricardo solved the problems met during
development of top power S S-V engines by making the Sleeve Open,
something like an annular piston, 10% of the piston surface, that
contributed with 3% of the total engine output via the Sleeve-Valve
operating mechanism and the crankshaft, this also eliminated the very
complex 'Junk head', of former S S-V engines. The clean air acts had
an influence on the SFC of car engines, as a clean exhaust required a
bit of fuel consumption increase, but I was told about an experience
around 1975 with a Seat/Fiat 4 cylinder, OHV, camshaft in the block
side, 1438 cc car engine being measured an SFC of 178 gr/HP/hr,
pretty good.
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.