Subject: Single Rotor balance:FAO paul Lamar
From: "rotaryeng@earthlink.net" <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Date: 4/23/2015, 11:03 AM
To: AA-1-Me


    Centrifugal force of a rotating object is MVVR.  Where V is the
    velocity, and R the radius and M is mass.

    This means that unless C.G. is matched exactly, it is impossible to
    ballance the engine at different speed.

    Fortunately, I think the C.G. Of the rotor travels in a circle.
    Therefore it is van be balanced by a weight at the C.G. path of the
    rotor. The same goes for the imbalance of the eshaft.

    Since counter weight is located only at the end of the engine, I
    think you will get from limited twisting on the shaft.

    That's IMHO. No guarantee on accuracy.

    Henry Nee
    Hi,

    Can you please explain the problem and solution of balancing when
    using  a cut down e-shaft  with single rotor 1/2 Mazda 13b engine.

    Regards Zahid


    Balance is controlled by these equations. The Wankel is not just
    statically balanced but dynamically balanced as well.

    In a single rotor engine the counterbalance weights must provide a
    STATIC balance for the e-shaft eccentric and its rotor and must also
      account for the DYNAMIC wobble caused because the static counter
    weights are not located at the mechanical centres of the rotor and
    the eccentric. It is impossible to do this.

    They must be mathematically sized relative to their lateral position
      from the rotor and eccentric centre line.

    Paul Lamar


    the Tracy ISO is physically attached to the flywheel. Does that need
      to be brought in to balance equation  as extra mass to mF (front
    counter weight) or mR (mass Rear Counterweight)?

    Regards Zahid

    The rear counter weight is hiding behind the ISO.

    Paul Lamar

    Here is how I solved some of the balancing issues. There are a whole
      lot of issues interacting when building a new engine configuration.
      Weight control influences almost everything. A single rotor engine
    certainly requires a considerable flywheel, if one wants the idle
    speed somewhere below 3000 RPM. I integrated the rear balance weight
      in the flywheel (picture). The front balance weight I modified with
      tungsten inserts before dynamic balancing. I ended up with a clean
    rotating setup. My engine is based on 12A rotor and housing, so I do
      not have any direct comparison to 13B size parts. FWIW.


    Richard Sohn N2071U

    http://www.fairpoint.net/~res12/home.html


    Hi Richard, I have read some postings where some have machined a
    single rotor eccentric shaft from a 2 rotor unit. Paul mentions the
    shaft needs to be hardened after machining. Could you give a overview
    of the process you used to build your shaft ?

    Thanks, Steve Carlisle

    Here is what I did.

    On the first e-shaft I concerted, I left the oil pump side of the
    shaft with the front lobe unchanged. After machining the rear end of
      the shaft to my mods, I only had one bearing surface to create. I
    picked an inner ring of a INA needle bearing with an outer diameter
    the same as the original MAZDA bearing, and pressed it on the shaft.
      As it turned out, it was a solution, which never failed during all
    the ground testing of the first engine I build, with a run time of
    around 50hrs. I did not consider this a solution for a final, flyable
    configuration. The solution I have in the engine now is a case
    hardened bearing section. The biggest problem was finding someone for
    the case hardening and grinding who was willing to do it for and
    affordable cost. FWIW


    Richard Sohn N2071U

    http://www.fairpoint.net/~res12/home.html


    I misunderstood the last email by Richard Sohn. He was referring to
    case hardening process for e shaft . I thought he was referring to
    case hardening for bearing. So please do not publish my last email.

    Zahid Rahman



    I am thinking, since the rotor rotates at one third the speed of the
      esfaft. One needs a 3:1 reduction gear on the counter weight to
    matched the rotor's rotation speed.

    Corrections welcome!

    Henry Nee


    I'm not sure at all, but you have to compensate for the weight that
    is centered in the shaft eccentric, and this rotates at shaft speed.
    Or not? Thanks. Best regards. Salut † Jose Gros-Aymerich Madrid,
    Spain


    Yes, I believe you need two counter weights. One rotates at reduced
    speed to balance the rotor, and a second one in same speed with the
    eshaft.

    That's why two rotors is much better balanced.

    Henry  Nee



    Guys/Gals,

    Read the post that Paul put up today at 13:15.  The motion of the rotor
    has nothing to do with the required balance weight attached to the
    E-shaft.  No reduced speed, no increased speed, just E-shaft speed.


         Mark LaPierre

Mark,

Just want to be a little clearer. As I have been mislead before and I would like to make it clear what the balancing is on, and hopefully others don't make the same mistake I did before.

To start, I'd like to retract my opinion that there needs to be a speed reduction of 1:3. After studying it more, I notice that the C.G of the Rotor, does travel at the same rpm as the eshaft.

Let me explain. I think we need to balance two things.

1. The Eshaft
2.The orbital rotation of the rotor (the rotor is already balanced when it self rotates).

The need to heavily balance the Eshaft is obvious, as it has only one disc instead of two opposing disc as in the case of a two rotor.

There is a second need to balance the force of the rotor as it orbits around the eshaft.

However, when we account for the fact that the C.G. of the rotor actually rotates in sync with the eshaft, then there is need to only balance the whole system once. Eshaft and all. The two balancing weights can be combined into a single one, and can work at all rpm.

The outcome is consistent with the suggested practice of a single balancing weight. Even though it really is balancing two different components at the same time.

Sorry about the mistake I make earlier. Hope this clear things up for those who were confused like me about Wankel Rotary, and can take the myth out on how to balance the thing.

regards,

Henry

Henry you may have missed this while you were over seas.

Paul Lamar

    The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
    ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
    You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
    Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.