I have been doing some research on the best resin to use for
composite tanks in the time to climb engine running on alcohol.
Looks like Vinyl Ester is the best.
I would make up a sample of the resin you are using and soak it in
car gas containing alcohol.
Paul Lamar
Ten to 15 years ago,I recall in a JC Auto Shop in Arizona that a
number of shop cars had to have the internal tank rubber hoses
replaced because the long time exposure to the old gas and warm
temperature caused them to deteriorate and leak. Any tests on fuel
resistance should long term exposure and elevated temperatures.
Joel Over the Hill Materials Engr.
Paul, you will probably find that full strength epoxy is a better choice
than vinyl ester (which is essentially a polyester resin with epoxy
chains in it, as I understand it) particularly if you are building with
carbon fibre or kevlar, or trying to bond other things to the
fibreglass, and being stronger you can use less of it. All of these
resins will absorb and be degraded by components in gasoline and
ethanol, but if you are running nearly pure ethanol it may be easier to
track down. It's also probably not a big issue for that plane if all the
fuel will be used up in a few minutes ;) Resins that resist alcohol
better, like phenol-formaldehyde (novolac) aren't necessarily as strong.
For a discussion of the chemistry of ethanol eating composites, see
http://www.boatus.com/seaworthy/fueltest.asp It's not a simple issue,
for testing methods see also
http://www.steeltank.com/Portals/0/Shop%20Fab/SteelAndAlternativeFuels/kass.biofuels.tuesday.pdf
David Josephson
Not a Materials Engr.
Thanks David. I know the boat industry has had a lot of problems
but I assumed it was because they used polyester. Some people
on here have had problems but I am not sure they were using epoxy.
In my research I did run across novolac.
Is it head and shoulders above ordinary epoxy?
Paul Lamar
Paul, et.al.,
As a Glasair builder, I’ve had a lot of experience with vinyl-ester
resins. The Glasair is built with Derakane 411-45 (IIRC) and uses
integral gas tanks. The stuff you get from Aircraft Spruce, 411-350 is
similar. I ran some witness sample tests of cured fibreglass layups and
found some surprising results. I used both factory cured samples and
cured samples of my own.
According to the Derakane web site, these resins are supposed to be ok
with gasohol up to 10% ethanol. What I found was not that simple.
The witness samples were tested in some Jack Daniels, gasohol from my
local gas station (tested to be 7% ethanol) and 100 LL avgas. Both
samples soaked in the Jack Daniels and the gasohol developed a white
sticky goo (my technical term) on the surface of the sample. This was
true of both the factory cured sample and the self made sample. I
attribute this goo to a reaction of the very top layer of the resin that
never totally cured and the alcohol content of the medium. There have
been a number of sources that indicate that the layer of resin exposed
to the air never really gets totally cured.
I scraped the goo layer off of the samples and put them in a fresh
solution of Jack and gasohol. There was no more goo after that. I
concluded that putting gasohol in my tanks was a bad idea, regardless of
how the rest of the system tolerated the ethanol. Also, there was no
reaction at all on the witness samples to 100 LL avgas.
Also, IIRC, some epoxy-based glass aircraft builder, one of the canard
style aircraft, I don’t remember which one, had his gas tank develop
major leaks after filling up with gasohol. The alcohol ate right
through his tank. I also don’t know what type of epoxy resin he used.
He had to open his wing and rebuild the tanks.
Bottom line- don’t trust the claims of the resin manufacturer. Run some
witness sample tests of your own before deciding on a resin system.
Steve Thomas
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Store
http://www.rotarpower.com/#!
Copyright 1998-2015
All world wide rights reserved.