Subject: Low HP single rotor engine Verses VW
From: paul lamar
Date: 7/27/2015, 8:19 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink




Here I am thinking I have flown many hours in gyros only to now find
it can't be done!Weary face I started out with direct drive 1800 cc
VW, the prop was 52 inch limiting rpm to under 3000, above that it
was just noise as the tips went transonic.

We built 1.85:1 tooth belt reduction allowing the rpm to go to 4500.
Performance was quite good. We reckon it had about 80 hp. The Subaru
EA 81 would have had similar hp.

Health problems brought an end to my ambitions of completing a
Tractor gyro powered by a turbo Mazda 12A rotary. It was to be jump
take off machine. We elected to run the drive shaft up to the centre
of the hub bar, but I couldn't find a suitable light gearbox, it
needed to handle 120 ft lbs to overspeed the rotor. The best rotor
rpm I saw was just under 200 before various gearboxes failed, we were
looking for about 550.

The rotor pitch change worked well so we could comply with Oz
requirements to only change pitch FOR flight not IN flight, although
I Thought it would be great to overspeed the rotor on approach by
partially de pitching it to store energy in it and then have control
over the amount of lift as you settle on. I'd love someone to finish
the project.

John Evans


Maybe I should have said plus or minus 20.
What did you weigh John when you did that?
What type of carbs were you using on the VW?
What did you do to the displacement?
The original engines were about 36 HP as I recall.

Paul Lamar



Sorry to be slow answering your questions Paul, we had a few
problems with Internet. I guess I would have been about 95 kg
(200lbs) .

The VW had twin Holley "Bugspray" carbs. Once I fitted the toothed
belt reduction it took a while to get it to cool properly with the
higher output, I had to scoop air from above my left shoulder with
plastic drainpipe fittings on the left, the airflow to the heads on
the right were less of a problem.

The cooling problems were investigated by using temperature
sensitive adhesive strips, they would show the maximum temp
experienced by that part of the head. Air cooled engines can be a
pain to cool.

As far as I can recall we got the 1800 cc capacity by going to 92 mm
bore, longer stroke cranks were available to go to 2100 cc.

The EA 81 Subaru ended up with throttle body fuel injection from a
Holden Camira, it worked well but the engine would snuff on late
final if I didn't manually lean the mixture.


John Evans


FWIW, the direct-drive 2180cc VWs are putting out about 80 reliable
hp these days (typically they max out at about 3600 RPM, due to prop
pitch).  People have fitted them with redrives to let them rev
higher, and with the right cam they can put out up to about 100 HP
that way, but usually not for very long due to head temperatures--lot
of tricks have been tried.  Sonex is now going full tilt with a turbo
version of their Aerovee VW conversion that will give more than 80
HP, but boost has to be mild to avoid overheating the heads--I think
people will primarily use it for turbonormalizing at higher
altitudes.

Again, the exhaust valve brings limits the great plans--Felix
Wankel's innovation clearly wins out in this regard.  But in hp per
dollar, the well-explored VW is still bringing a lot of smiles to a
lot of aviators.   I'm hoping the Mazda will someday become for the
160-200HP requirement what the VW is for the 60-80 HP world.  But
there are lot of published guides and a few vendors specializing in
VW aviation parts--its a lot sparser and more "experimental" in the
Mazda world (something Paul knows very well).

Mark Waldron.

Maybe at 3600 RPM or above. You take a enormous prop efficiency hit
at 3600 RPM and the exhaust valves are still the Achilles heel right
from the days of the 36 HP and beyond. A geared VW makes more sense.


I went through SCCA race driver school back in the early 1960's in a
split window. The problem is the head design. The cooling fins are
not near enough and long enough.

My O-470 goes through at least one exhaust valve per 500 hours and it
was designed from the get go to be an aircraft engine

It is a lot cheaper to cut down a 2 rotor eccentric  shaft than buy a
forged 2100 CC VW crankshaft.

Paul Lamar


Yes Paul, I was planning to go the single rotor route and started hacking into an e shaft, unfortunately my poor little myford lathe wasn't up to it. I now have a bigger lathe but am limited to less ambitious projects - adapting e bike hub motors to my disability aid.
I got 11 fractures 7 of them spinal when an old patient turned across in front of me, he thought by  BMW was a gap in the traffic. He was a nice bloke and I was saddened to learn he died from stomach cancer a few days ago.

John Evans




The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the
list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.