Subject: I have never been able to design a PC board that worked from the get go.
From: paul lamar
Date: 8/5/2015, 9:09 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


I have been doing it off and on since the early 70's starting with
tape and mylar.

Is this just me? :-)

Good thing I only populated it partially and tested it with a current
limited power supply! If I had connected it to a 12 volt car battery
it would have melted the PC board and burned down the hangar!!


Paul Lamar

I started in the late 70s with tape and mylar and was thrilled to
toss all the last cir-kit transfers in the trash about 20 years ago.
I use Cadsoft Eagle, there is a free version. You can confirm that
the board matches the schematic and none of the traces will short
out. That's enough for me. The last dozen or so layouts have worked
the first time for me.

David Josephson

Thanks for the tip David. I'll take a look. I assume you have to do a
 wire list and input a schematic or can you just input integrated
circuit part numbers?
You input a schematic that references parts in a library, it generates a
wire list (called a netlist.)

Can you send me a sample input file?
I'll do that. The demo package includes tutorial files too. There is a
lot of online support, forums etc.

I use ExpressPCB directly. I don't enter a schematic or bill of
materials into ExpressSCH. I have never used it.
You can do that in Eagle too, but you still have to generate the parts
in the layout editor and it will not build a schematic from a pcb
layout, only the other way around.

Perhaps that is what I am doing wrong. I tried one of those programs
in the distant past and I was not happy with the part layout. There
is sometimes more to the part layout than just all the proper
connections.


Is there a free  schematic editor with Cadsoft?

The thing about ExpressPCB is the boards are cheap and the service is
pretty fast. They do charge for UPS 2nd day shipping when parcel
post would be as fast and cost way less. Submitting your design is
fast and easy as they have a web site that accepts your design file
directly in mere seconds.


Paul Lamar

PL: "There is sometimes more to the part layout than just all the proper
connections."

Often -- but in Eagle you can edit the library as you like, then update
the schematic and board files and the changes you made to the libraRY
update the layouts. When you're done with the schematic it will generate
a BOM for you. The libraries include both US and European versions of
component symbols (like boxes for resistors in the EU version vs. zigzag
lines for US resistors) and there are some parts on metric (2.5 mm grid)
and imperial (0.1 inch grid.) You can mix and match as you like, and
constrain the schematic lines and pcb traces to the grid you define, or
leave them floating.

PL: "Is there a free  schematic editor with Cadsoft?"

There is. There are basically four components: a library editor, a
schematic editor,  a pc board layout program and an autorouter (that's
part of the pc board program.) Then there is a macro language and a
post-processor that does things like generate part lists, BOMs, plot
files and NC drill and routing files. It works best if you invest the
time to understand the whole workflow starting with the library editor,
where you define parts the way you want them to appear on the schematic
and on the pcb. There are already hundreds of libraries for most common
parts. You open a library, pick parts from it and drop them onto the
schematic, wire up the pins as you want, which generates a netlist -- a
net is a group of pins that are all connected together. Then you switch
to the pcb where you see a generic board outline and a stack of parts,
with "airwire" lines for the nets connecting them. You arrange the parts
on the pcb and the airwires follow, showing you the closest pins that
are all connected. Then you can either use the autorouter or you can
manually route traces to replace the airwires. It will tell you how many
airwires are left to route.


ExpressPCB is good but they want to lock you into their service. I use
Advanced Circuits who have a bunch of different pricing and shipping
options, and they use industry-standard Gerber and Excellon files. If
you set up a business account they will give you the first pcb free.
There are student and barebones (no soldermask or silkscreen) and other
cheap deals too. The barebones is the best deal.

PL: "The downside to doing it my way is once you submit the design you pay
for the possibly defective boards no matter what :-("


That's always the case. But if you have a modern program at least you
can do an engineering rule check (to see that the pcb matches the
schematic) and a design rule check (to see that the traces don't
overlap.) It's a lot of learning curve to get comfortable with these
tools but if you're doing more than one board it's worth it. I resisted
learning the whole workflow for a long time and it was frustrating, now
it's much easier.

David

I'll give it a try when I get back from AusFly. I cobbled up the board to get
it working for my demo unit at AusFly.


Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will
remove  you.  ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.