This is an excerpt from a book by Herschel Smith called "A History of
Aircraft Piston Engines" published by Sunflower University Press Inc. 1531
Yuma, Manhattan, Kansas 66502-4228. ISBN 0-07-058472-9. There are
250, 8.5 by 11 pages. It chronicles the evolution of the [light]
aircraft engine from
early days to the present. There are many tables listing every engine
ever put in an airplane with all important specifications including weight,
horsepower, RPM, configuration and in some cases BSFC. There are many
photos and drawings of all types of intermittent combustion aircraft
engines.
This is as close to a bible of intermittent combustion aircraft engine
history
that I have found so far. No jets or turbo props.
The conclusion is a major reason on why the Wankel makes such a good
light aircraft engine.
"Chapter TEN The opposed engine.
The Rationale of the Opposed Engine
Every piston engine in production today, outside of the Soviet bloc, is
of the opposed type. It has displaced all others wherever buyers. and
designers are free to choose.
Its merits lie not in any single area of outstanding superiority but in
having an optimum combination of qualities for today's conditions and
airframe designs.
The replacement of a radial by a flat engine in the Bellanca
demonstrates this combination. In its pre-war incarnation as the model
14, the Cruisair was a two- to three-place airplane powered by a 95-hp
Ken-Royce radial. By 1948 it had become a four-placer with a 150-hp
Franklin opposed six up front. Eventually it went over 200 hp with a
flat engine and acquired a tricycle gear. Visibility over the nose of
the original model was barely acceptable; with a 150-hp radial it would
have been impossible. A 150-hp radial would have had a diameter over the
cowling of about 44 in. (1120 mm), more than the fuselage width and high
enough to demand extra fuselage depth in order to let the pilot see past
the engine. To begin with, then, both visibility and streamlinIng are
better on small planes when opposed engines are used.
In addition, there is usually no weight penalty involved in the use of
an opposed engine instead of a radial. A radial would be lighter for the
same power if it had the same number of cylinders, but it doesn't; in
the interest of smoothness, it needs more. A major source of vibration
that plagues other types of engines is largely eliminated on opposed
engines because their pistons come together and move apart in pairs, and
this makes it practical to use fewer but larger cylinders. This, as we
have noted earlier, makes for a lighter engine and allows the flat
engine to be at least competitive with the small radial with regard to
weight. Modem vibration-absorbing mounts help, of course. Because of
both of these factors, we can now make flat fours in sizes that would
have called for 7 cylinders in a radial.
The rpm of opposed engines tend to be higher than those of radials. This
is a disadvantage from the standpoint of propulsive efficiency, but this
is minimized by the availability of constant-speed propellers in the
lower power ranges. In addition, the higher revs call for smaller
propeller diameters, which go well with tricycle gear."
The distance from the eccentric shaft to the top of the Wankel is no
larger than most horizontal
opposed aircraft engines and mounting the turbo charger on one side and
the cooling system
on the other fits most side by side aircraft perfectly.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux.
If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will
remove you. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.