Paul et al,
I have what is probably a basic question.
I have often read that a propeller induces adverse vibrations into a
drive train and that a belt driven PSRU is the way to isolate those
vibrations from the rest of the components and engine in general
while allowing the propeller and engine to each operate in their
most effective rpm range. Yet I also see a lot of planetary (and
other?) gear drive units, especially in the information shared here,
that would seem likely to transmit those propeller vibrations. So in
the applications being discussed here how is a direct drive
permissible? Is it because the aircraft (e.g. the time to climb) are
limited purpose and limited life and thus not likely to be adversely
affected in the time they are operational?
Just curious and hoping to understand better. Thanks for any
responses!
Brad Chubb
The planetary was universally used in aircraft engines for years.
Only in WW II was a spur gear used in the water cooled V12's. All
the radials had planetary gear box's including the largest aircraft
engine ever made in quantity. That was the P&W R 4360 Wasp Major. It
had 18 planet gears. The latests in large P&W turbo fan engines for
airliners is a planetary gear box that is 98% efficient.
Direct drive requires a lot of displacement for a limited amount of
HP. The 2 rotor rotary engine is small displacement as aircraft
engine go at 160 cubic inches. However the time to climb engine is a
record amount of HP (650) for it's weight of under 250 pounds with
gear box.
BTW The rotary is also a record amount of HP per cubic inch of
displacement at 4 HP per cubic inch. The former record holder was the
Offenhouser race engine at 3 HP per cubic inch.
The TTC record holder Grumman Bearcat had 2 pounds per HP to lift
while our TTC aircraft (Vans RV4 basically) only has 1.5 pounds per
HP to lift. Weight per HP is the name of the game in high climb
performance. Ask any truck driver :-)
We are about done with the installation and we are waiting until Dan
Gray gets back from vacation to test run the engine on the aircraft.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
I think that F1 engines in 2005, in the final year of the 3.0-liter
V-10 era, were making about 900 hp and weighed less than 200 pounds.
That would be 4.5 hp per pound. Of course, they were spinning to
19,000 rpm.
Csaba Csere
I also think they were allowed Beryllium Aluminium pistons made from
surplus Russian atomic war head material. BeAl is .7 the density of
aluminium and will tolerate 600 F. As I understand it, BeAl is now
outlawed in F1 due to its toxic nature.
We are turning only 6500 RPM now because of the current 3:1 gear box
and the 84 inch diameter prop. If we used a 4:1 gear box (available
in one planetary) we could turn 11,000 RPM. Many Mazda RX7 road
racing engines use that red line. If that were the case we would
have 1100 HP.
Here is such a 4:1 planetary. This one may not be up to the required
torque so it would have to be scaled up but I doubt it would weigh
much more than the current 3:1 Bell 47 final drive.
If we replaced the current 20 pounds of cast iron rotors and counter
weights with 4.2 pounds of BeAl we could double the RPM and the HP
to 2200 HP roughly speaking. Of course the engine weight would be
well under 200 pounds as well.
Paul Lamar
Hi Paul, I seemed to have missed the discussion on using the jeep
transfer case planetary's for a PSRU . Are you proposing using the 4
to 1 unit?
Thanks, Steve Carlisle
Well we tried hard to buy just the planet carrier. No luck. Seemed
the only way to get one was buy the whole transfer case. No problem
for a bucks up Reno racer but I doubt it would live with a 1000 HP
three rotor or even the time to climb engine.
I gave up. Too rich for my blood :-)
It has some what of a bad reputation for failing.
It might work for a NA 13B p-port however. If you used it you might
get 300 HP at 9 to 10,000 RPM with a reasonable diameter prop.
The sun works on one diameter of the planet gears and the sun gear
reacts the other diameters for 4 to one reduction.
Paul Lamar
A 4:1 box would work! Lets get away from 1000 hp, the average home
builder would be pleased with 220 hp.
A survey by the homebuilders about 40 years ago indicated that the
average homebuilder only flew his project at most 500 hours. Set
realistic times for overhaul, say 1000 hours, etc before inspection,
that’s a reasonable target.
The local Jeep guy sold me a used heavy duty transfer case for $100
bucks, and I am in the process of dis assy it now, It appears to me
it would do 300 hp no problem. Ratio is 2.71 ratio. Tag says 245J,
5210-5703AA Built like a Brick S___ House. I am doing this to see
what's inside and how it is put together!
Milo
You can buy just the 3:1 Ford planetary's new all day long from an
auto transmission parts supply. Hundreds have been flown since 1973.
Why mess with something not as good with no history. We have many
dwgs on how to assemble them in effective PSRU's. Why start from
scratch? Now if you Jeep guy has a 4:1 I would be interested.
Paul Lamar
Its kinda fun to say you can get 1000 hp at 11000 rpm and I’m sure
you can but that’s a real big radiator and the exhaust is going to be
a very impressive sight. Would work for a quarter mile run maybe.
ray atkinson
All true.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want
off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you. ACRE NL web
site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.