Subject: P&W planetary gear box.
From: "rotaryeng@earthlink.net" <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Date: 4/18/2016, 6:05 AM
To: A10-me-earthlink





Paul et al,

I have what is probably a basic question.

I have often read that a propeller induces adverse vibrations into a
drive train and that a belt driven PSRU is the way to isolate those
vibrations from the rest of the components and engine in general
while allowing the propeller and engine to each operate in their
most effective rpm range. Yet I also see a lot of planetary (and
other?) gear drive units, especially in the information shared here,
that would seem likely to transmit those propeller vibrations. So in
the applications being discussed here how is a direct drive
permissible? Is it because the aircraft (e.g. the time to climb) are
limited purpose and limited life and thus not likely to be adversely
affected in the time they are operational?

Just curious and hoping to understand better. Thanks for any
responses!

Brad Chubb

The planetary was universally used in aircraft engines for years.
Only in WW II was a spur gear used in the water cooled V12's. All
the radials had planetary gear box's including the largest aircraft
engine ever made in quantity. That was the P&W R 4360 Wasp Major. It
had 18 planet gears. The latests in large P&W turbo fan engines for
airliners is a planetary gear box that is 98% efficient.

Direct drive requires a lot of displacement for a limited amount of
HP. The 2 rotor rotary engine is small displacement as aircraft
engine go at 160 cubic inches. However the time to climb engine is a
record amount of HP (650)  for it's weight of under 250 pounds with
gear box.

BTW The rotary is also a record amount of HP per cubic inch of
displacement at 4 HP per cubic inch. The former record holder was
the Offenhouser race engine at 3 HP per cubic inch.

The TTC record holder Grumman Bearcat had 2 pounds per HP to lift
while our TTC aircraft (Vans RV4 basically)  only has 1.5 pounds per
HP to lift. Weight per HP is the name of the game in high climb
performance. Ask any truck driver :-)

We are about done with the installation and we are waiting until Dan
Gray gets back from vacation to test run the engine on the aircraft.

Paul Lamar


Paul, I had one other question about the P&W planetary. Are there
two outer gears so they can put one on from each side? That was the
only way I could think of that I could think of to put them all
together. there are splines on the sun gear to fit the drive shaft.
There are also on the outer ring gear but they are split so it looks
like they both come in from the outside. Bill Jepson


I don't know. The device is on display at the P&W museum in
Connecticut.

Paul Lamar


I can not remember from the last photos but if the planetary is
built with two carriers with opposing helix, then for removal the
planet carriers could be removed from each end. The two carriers
could be through bolted.

Dale Davies

Dale, I agree that the carrier's could be bolted together. But if
you look at the P&W planetary the Herringbone, ( double "V"), gears
internally all appear to be single piece. I'm not certain how the
final assembly is done.

Bill Jepson


It appears that the ring gear is split.  That would allow you to
assemble the sun and planet gears into an assembly then slip the two
ring gears on from each side to complete the assembly.

Mark LaPierre



Yes Mark, That is exactly what I implied. The fixed gears would need
to be very precisely timed so they wouldn't load the planets and sun
gear.

Bill Jepson


Well actually, the gear lash of the entire assembly could be made
adjustable by the careful application of a bit of timing adjustment.
This is typically accomplished with spur gears using a spring loaded
section that removes any gear lash from timing critical systems such as
valve position indicators or inside dial indicators used on machine work.

Perhaps a pin with a few thousandths of eccentricity could be used to
offset the two gears just enough to tighten out any excessive clearance
in the gear assembly.  You would only need to do that at one spot on the
ring gear.  Several other spots around the ring could then be reamed and
pinned into position to lock the orientation or the ring assembly.

Unfortunately this plan would interfere with using the reactive thrust
of the gear to measure torque through compression on a thrust bearing.
There should be no axial thrust to measure with the "Herringbone" cut gears.

 Mark LaPierre

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux.
If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will
remove  you.  ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.