Subject: PT6 verses the Wankel
From: "rotaryeng@earthlink.net" <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
Date: 5/5/2016, 11:30 AM
To: A10-me-earthlink




  Can't wait for the PT6 comparison, Rotary comparison, We run a
  PT6-27 in the Turbo Beaver, CF-OES

  Steve Carlisle

  What is the fuel burn Steve? What HP level do you cruise it at ?

  Some of the data I have is 650 HP for five minutes and 500 HP
  continuous. 227 US gallons with a range 767 statue miles.  That is
  3.38 miles per gallon.

  Max cruise speed is 202 MPH. So 767 miles by 3.79 hours. 227
  divided by 3.38 is  60 gallons an hour.  Diesel fuel is about 7
  pounds per gallon or 420 pounds of fuel per hour.  That translate
  to a BSFC of  420 divided by 500 HP or .84 BSFC.

http://www.wipaire.com/myaircraft/dehavilland/DHC2_MK1/modifications.php#bossbeaver

A turbo 3 rotor could make 500 HP all day long with a worst case BSFC
  (full rich, not leaned) of .65 BSFC. Leaned it is .47 BSFC or about
  half the fuel burn of a PT6.. A turbo compound version would drop
  the fuel burn to below .4.

  The turbo 3 rotor wins hands.  The cost of a PT6 is well above
  $200,000 as I recall. One can build a lot of turbo 3 rotors with
  stock Mazda rotor housings and stock Mazda rotors for $200,000. The
  weight is likely to be half of  the weight of a PT6. The turbo is
  off the shelf as is the necessary oil and water pumps.  A PT6 gear
  box could be used.

  However the 3 rotor is not certified (yet) so you cannot take paid
  passengers.

  BTW My son, James Paul Lamar, has lots of hours in twin otter's
  with PT6's. What is your fuel burn JP?

  Paul Lamar

  Paul, I just get to play with it every once in a while. It is
  "thirsty" as they say. No matter how heavy it gets loaded, it just
  laugh's !!! The turbine in it now as installed about a year ago,
  Canada Surplus accidentally listed 3 for auction, I think it was
  purchased for 230 thousand, CDN. Apparently wrong stickers and the
  pencil pushers sold them off, OOPPPPPS ! The Rotary project is
  exciting.

  Steve  Carlisle

We have a Czech copy in  the hangar but it is non certified.
Experimental aircraft only. I think the crop dusters may have
protested the FAA and got it approved for use on crop dusting
aircraft. I am not sure about that. It is a good and reliable engine.


The Mazda Wankel in four rotor form and ceramic apex seals
would give it a real run for the money. Some engine manufacturer
needs to wake up and get it certified. Mistral almost did it but
were hungup by by Mistrail's insisting on EFI. The FAA does
not like EFI as it is too hard for them to read the source code
and figure out what happens when. Mistrial should have used
an aircraft carburettor. Something the FAA understands.
Lycoming has been trying for years to get EFI certified.

Paul Lamar

What is the cost range of a hot section inspection and overhaul for the
650HP PT6?

Dale Davies


re: Twin Otter Fuel BurnMan that was 35 years ago now!We operated the series 400 (2xPT6-34) with long range tanks (478 US Gal).The longest trip we did was just short of 900nm (Yellowknife to Kuujjuaq lower Ungava Bay)We only had about 40 gals left at the end!I looked this up on the wiki for what it's worth ....Power/Mass - 0.12 hp/lb (0.20 kW/kg) or 8.33 lb/hp (5 kg/kW) reciprocal value
Note that our max climb rate was 1600 ft/min

140 TAS but we had a nice tail wind going east at angels 25!


JP Lamar


I found some BSFC and weight  data on the P&W web site.
Looks like it is around .6 BSFC on average.

Looks like next week

Paul Lamar




  The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want
  off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL
  web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
  http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide
  rights reserved.