Subject: Converting charge cooling to oil cooling.
From: paul lamar
Date: 5/20/2016, 10:26 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


Hi Paul: Although my project has been stalled for several years, I still
plan on pursuing using the over 40 of the OMC single-rotor engines I
have that were in the Evinrude/Johnson snowmobiles in the 1970's.

I know, you're not crazy about charge-cooled rotaries, but I see an
opportunity to gently use them w/out demanding all the horses they can
produce. I felt, in my very-amateur opinion, that Eric Barger was too
optimistic w/ the power he would be getting from his ROTORMAX line of
rotaries.

So, I've been paying attention to your ideas of using set screws instead
of a bolt all the way through the eccentric shaft as Tracy C. did.

The idea is to couple two (possibly more) together to produce 70-90 hp
(OMC's first ones were rated @ 35 hp @ 5,500 rpms, and then later, 45 hp
@ 6,500 rpms) for flying purposes. I chose the OMCs for several reasons.
The main reason was after talking w/ one of their engineers over the
phone that was retired in the Chicago area many years after OMC shut
down. He said those engines were well-built, and weren't really being
taxed too hard in snowmobile use.

Severe back problems (partially caused by jerking around one of the OMC
engines that had seized after I foolishly revved it to over 8K rpms
w/out a load on it) & working too many hours are my excuses. Now
recently retired, the back problems are mostly a thing of the past, but
on limited funds, unlike before.

Before I retired, I was able to acquire those OMC engines, as well as
donate that $500 toward your TC project, when I had extra funds! Still
plan on donating some funds for each OMC engine sold in the future to
your(?) Everett Hatch fund.

Also, have acquired one of the Aixro-50 engines to attempt an ultralight
gyroplane, too.

A big distraction after back problems have greatly diminished has been
switching over from a Rotax 503 (52 hp) to one of the Yamaha three
cylinder,120 hp, four-stroke snowmobile engines on my Sport Copter gyro.

I've trailered it out-of-state several times to El Mirage dry lake bed,
Santa Maria, & Yreka in CA, to Yuma, AZ, Brigham City, UT, and Mentone,
IN, for gyro flying at events in those locations. Also many times to
Alvord desert dry lake bed in far SE Oregon. Love that Yamaha power!

Hope to love the smoothness of rotary power flying a gyro in the future.
Have acquired three different gearboxes to work w/ the OMCs. Had a
machinist cut a Rotax taper into one of the eccentric shafts to use w/
one of the Rotax drive gears for an "A" gearbox (2.58:1 reduction). He
said the hardening treatment OMC put on that ecc. shaft was a killer to
overcome, dulling three of his cutters!

Kevin Richey
Portland, OR


If you don't mind a visit I am planing on being in Portland shortly. I
would like to look
at those engines and take a few photos if you don't mind.

I have an idea based on some of what we have learned on the TTC engine
of converting
a charged cooled engine  to oil cooled. We drill a hole in the E-shaft
and feed high pressure oil in from
one end using an off the shelf Barns dry sump pump. Then we drill a
holes to feed
the plain rotor and main  bearings. It can be made plain by installing a
simple bushing where the roller
bearing was, Next we drill and oil squirter hole to cool the rotor. Then
the Barnes can
be used to scavenge the oil with out installing an oil pan.

The hardness of the shaft is not a problem because once you get through
the hard shell it become
softer in the center. Modern carbide drills will do the trick. If that
does not work
we can heat them locally and normalize them in that small area .
We can re harden them later if necessary.


Paul Lamar

Also one can use EDM to drill holes in hard steel. This opens up a bunch
of possibilities
perhaps we can modify an AIXRO to make it oil cooled. The TTC engine
also opened my
eyes to other possibilities. Once you have an external oil pump and
scavenge pumps
a myriad of Wankel configurations are possible.


Paul Lamar


Squirting oil into the rotor to cool is sounds good, getting rid of the
ball bearing
  and using a sleeve bearing and then supplying it with oil also great.

How do you get the oil out of the rotor? With it spinning wouldn't
centripetal
forces sling the oil into the rotor?  How would you evacuate the oil
from around the e-shaft and the inside of the rotor?

I have several charge cooled wrankels I would luv to convert to oil
cooled too.

David Mikesell

What kind do you have David?

Paul Lamar


The mention of EDMing in hardened steel reminds me of an issue from a
previous life that provides a precautionary message to share.

In one of my previous jobs we EDMed small tight tolerance shearing
cutters out of hardened steel to cut leads off of electrical components
as part of an automated circuit board assembly process machine. The
overriding cutter required a "neck" to pass over the under riding cutter
and still fit within the under board adjacent component clearance
envelope. We had to EDM the cutters out of hardened material because if
we tried to fabricate with more traditional machining methods and then
harden the cutters they would distort out of tolerance and not shear the
leads effectively. That all seemed fine and we thought we had a process
to produce parts from. However we were seeing premature failure of the
overriding cutter in the neck area. Structural analysis and FEA analysis
indicated we should have had ample margin.

After a great deal of investigation and engineering analysis we came to
realize that the EDM process was creating a microscopic annealed layer
all the way around the profile of the cutter. Not only that but the soft
layer's surface had a roughness on a microscopic level across the grain
of the material. That roughness created stress concentration points at
which micro cracks would start. These would grow and eventually
propagate into the hardened material at which point the cutter failed
(sudden brittle fracture of the hardened material). We solved this by
EDMing a few thousandths oversize and then grinding the profile with the
grain of the material to the final dimensions to remove the annealed zone.

Certainly EDMing is a very valuable fabricating method with many
advantages and benefits. But please pardon me for providing a point that
may be understood by any or all of those who read this in that we need
to realize the potential for EDM to adversely affect the surface
hardness of hardened materials.

Hope that helps someone avoid a problem I had to figure out the hard way.

Regards,
Brad Chubb


We are putting small holes in a large low stress part. I doubt this will
cause any
problems. Also a carbide drill a slight bit larger would clean the
surface of the hole.

Paul Lamar


Based on your reply it seems like drilled hole tolerances will be acceptable and the risk of breaking the drill bit is low. Otherwise a carbide reamer might also suit your needs. Either way you remove that annealed material. Seems like your situation will be a lot more engineering friendly than what I faced. Yours being large low (static?) stress vs. mine which was small and high cycling stress.

Regards,
Brad Chubb


The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.