Subject: Reduce the heat loss to the coolant by half.
From: paul lamar
Date: 8/2/2016, 6:14 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


Double the thickness of the hard steel liner in the rotor housing.
This will result in a large reduction in fuel burn. BSFC.

A simple change that Mazda could do on the production line.


Paul Lamar

Hi Paul, How does a thicker liner give a reduced fuel burn; what is
the theory here?

Dave in Perth

One wants to keep as much heat (temperature)  in the combustion
chamber as possible. The steel liner acts as insulation as unusual as
that sounds. The heat transfer rate of steel is much much lower than
that of aluminum. So one would want to increase the thickness of
that insulation to prevent the aluminum from carrying  away all the
temperature.

As the combustion chamber rotates toward the exhaust port it is
exposed to new areas of the steel liner which are cooler and more and
more temperature  is lost. When one cools off a high pressurized
container the pressure is reduced in that container. This pressure is
acting on the face of the rotor and that is what generates the torque
so potential torque is lost.

(P1 X V1) / T1 = (P2 X V2)/ T2

Change any one of those terms in the first part and that  will
change the second part.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_laws

It is a fundamental law of physics.

Note: in this attached chart stainless steel  is 1/3 that of cast
iron. That is why Mazda needs to find out how to make the rotors out
of SS instead of cast iron. SS would be good for the liner as well if
it were possible to chrome plate it.

Also note: In the heat transfer units it is

watts / (meters X Temp)

so the thicker material the less heat is transfered.

Thermal details like this affect the BSFC of all engines.

Hold a piece of steel on a grinding wheel with your bare hands. Then
hold a piece of the same size SS and report back :-)

Paul Lamar


What is the heat transfer and cost of a ceramic coated rotor versus
a stainless steel rotor?

As temperatures increase of the combustion chamber and sliding
surfaces, what is expected to be the next weak link?  I suspect
carbon buildup would go down but will seal lubrication become an
issue?

Speaking of seal lubrication, which paper addresses why the apex
seals aren't lubricated from inside the rotor?


Aron Buster

"What is the heat transfer and cost of a ceramic coated rotor versus
a stainless steel rotor?"

I have no idea. Who is doing ceramic coating on rotors? I would
hesitate to use it because if some of it came off it would destroy
the wear surface of an expensive rotor housing.

The  proven Iannetti silicon nitride seals will tolerate double the
temperature of an iron seal. I have never heard of one breaking up in
17 years of this news letter. They are solid silicon nitride with
fiber reinforcement supposedly.

The main function of the apex seal oil is cooling the iron apex
seals. Synthetic oil will tolerate twice the temperature of organic
oils. Turbine oils are better than that.

If you use synthetic oil there is no carbon build up.

"Speaking of seal lubrication, which paper addresses why the apex
seals aren't lubricated from inside the rotor?"

You got me there. Do you know if there is such a paper? It might work
but the holes would have to be tiny and subject to plugging up if
some one used organic oils.

Also the amount of oil required is a function of horse power. I don't
know how one would control that with out a computer. Mixing with the
fuel already does that. More fuel, more oil, more power.


---------------------------------------------------------------------

 BTW the stock oil "injector pump" is not really a pump at all. It is
an oil distribution device. The oil is transfered to the compression
chamber when the chamber is lower pressure than atmospheric. The
so-called injectors are open to the atmospheric pressure.

If one turbo charges the RX7 engine less apex seal oil will find its
way to the apex seals. Mazda themselves made that mistake when they
turboed the rotary back in the late 80's and all of the 90's. If you
have one of those you better be mixing oil with the fuel :-)

Some people on the Internet get it wrong. They incorrectly assume
the RX7 "pump" AKA OMP is fed from the high pressure oil system. Not
true except possibly for the RX8. It is fed from a gravity fed
atmospheric pressure oil reservoir. To prove it take the RX7 "pump"
off and turn the engine over with the starter and see if oil squirts
out of the supply hole.


Paul Lamar


Hi Paul

I have looked quite a bit into ceramic coatings to act as thermal
insulation layer and as part of that I have talked to several world
experts on the subject matter

There are actually quite a few options for applying thermal coatings
onto metal surfaces and for the most part they can be applied to
many materials even some some low temp materials. Most are applied
with very high velocity impregnations. These nozzles are cnc
programmed to apply a pattern to get complete coverage

The issue is that I have not found any coaters who are able to
guarantee that the coating thickness will be uniform across the
surface being coated. This means than for the most part, the ceramic
surface will need to be lapped post coating process. This would make
this process coast prohibitive for low volume applications. Even for
high volume applications, it will be fairly expensive process because
the thermal insulating ceramics also tend to be extremely hard to to
lap.

With that said, if Mazda proceeds with releasing a new rotary, I am
pretty confident that they will utilize some sort of ceramic
insulating layer to help meet the more stringent regulations

Regards Simon Saba

Hi Simon, The rotor would only need to be coated on the three outer
surfaces, wouldn't it ? would they actually need to be lapped ?
doesn't only the apex seal contact the liner ? Chris Hoskins.


Don't do it Chris. You won't even notice it as it will be less than
1% lower fuel burn.

If a small part comes off you can kiss your engine good bye.

Also make sure you have a good air filter.

Paul Lamar


Hi Chris,

Paul is absolutely right You can coat on the opposite surface (ie
external surfaces surrounding the chamber) and indeed you will not
need to lap if on this surface instead of the internal surface. It
will still add insulation, however, because of the excellent
conductivity of the metal, the heat will conduct sideways (ie
radially) on the side plates, and axially and rotationally on the
housing. This will reduce the effectiveness of adding the insulation.
Certainly there will be an improvement but very small relative to
insulating the internal surfaces

The most effective, but unfortunately most expensive, is to insulate
the inside surfaces. On piston engines, there are several
aftermarket services that will coat the piston top and the inside
surface of the dome and it helps keep the heat inside by adding
insulation and reflecting radiated heat back in the piston. It would
be an interesting experiment for someone to coat the outer surfaces
of the rotor and quantify the impact.

Simon Saba

As long as there is no possibility of it coming  off.

A piston engine will tolerate more debris.

GM patented a multi piece rotor.

Paul Lamar

Some piston engine manufacturers are coating cylinder walls with a
ceramic for low wear. I think Ford is doing an aluminum V8 now. The
26B Lemans engine was ceremet coated to help BSFC and wear. I do not
know what development issues they may have had with that process.
Mazda must have had patents that describe the process. I believe the
rotor house and the side housings were coated. I would be interested
to know if they sprayed directly onto an aluminum housing or whether
they modified the steel liner for the ceremet thickness. Dale Davies


That was silicon carbide applied with a detonation gun. I guess you
could call it ceramic. It must be diamond ground. A very expensive
procedure. Mazda tried Nikasil and it was not as good as detonation
coating. Works better on cylinders.


The Ford may have been nikasil.

Nikasil is a trademarked electro deposited lipo philic nickel matrix
silicon carbide coating for engine components, mainly piston engine
cylinder liners.

Paul Lamar


By the diagram in the Lemans P-port illustration it appears the
ceremet was applied directly to the aluminum housing without a steel
liner.

Dale Davies



Wondering how they dealt with the different expansion rates of the
aluminum housing and the ceremet coating.  I'm imagining that ceremet is
brittle like other ceramics.

 Mark LaPierre

Silicon Carbide  is shot from guns at supersonic velocity and it embeds itself into
the aluminum with a mechanical lock. Carbide is very hard and strong. It is
widely used in NC machines as cutting tools.

It really works in the rotary.

They measured the wear on the 1991  Lemans engine over all winner after the race and
there was no detectable wear. The average RPM was 8500 for 24 hours.

Paul Lamar


The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.