Subject: Rotary options for LSA Austro Certified Ae50 rotary
From: paul lamar
Date: 9/23/2016, 8:29 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


 Does anyone have experience with rotary powered light sport aircraft?
 I know Austro makes the AE50R which from what I understand is in the
 under 80 lb weight range with a "no loss lubrication system" and is
 currently working on an 80 horsepower rotary to "replace" a Rotax 912
 80hp. Anyone know anything about these? Are there other less
 expensive options I haven't found yet?

 Jenn Kimball

 Nothing certified other than the Austro Engine. Over 500 of the 50
 HP versions have been sold to  Alexander Schleicher   motor gliders
 .

 LSA requires certification. There may be an LSA experimental
 category. I am not really all that up on the rules.


 Lots of Mazda one rotors however.

 What did you hear about 80 horsepower rotary to "replace" a Rotax
 912?

 Paul Lamar

 Light Sport Aircraft (LSA) fall under a specific definition of
 performance and capability set forth by the FAA.  They are not
 "certified" by definition.  There are three types of LSA.  LSA,
 factory built, S-LSA, Amateur built from a kit supplied by the
 manufacturer of the same factory built LSA model, and EAB-LSA.

 Light Sport Aircraft (LSA) are certified by their manufacturers, not
 the FAA, to be in compliance with ASTM standards.  There is no FAA
 certification for any of their equipment including engines.  They are
 granted an air worthiness certificate by the manufacturer. Like any
 other factory built aircraft they are not subject to Phase 1/2 fight
 testing .  They may not be legally modified without written
 permission from the manufacturer.  The condition inspection may be
 done by anyone who has completed a 40 hour course to become
 certified as an LSA inspector, or by an A&P Mechanic.  Factory built
 LSA my be rented and used for flight training.

 Special Light Sport Aircraft (S-LSA) are designed to be in compliance
 with the Light Sport Aircraft rules set forth by the FAA. They are
 amateur built to be fully in compliance with the factory built S-LSA
 version of the same aircraft.  They are granted an air worthiness
 certificate by the FAA.  S-LSA are subject to usual Phase 1/2 flight
 testing but only 20 hours of Phase 1 time.  S-LSA must comply with
 the factory specifications and may not be legally modified without
 written permission from the manufacturer. Condition inspections may
 be done by the builder, an LSA inspector, or an A&P Mechanic. S-LSA
 aircraft my not be used commercially or rented for any purpose.

 There is still the EAB class of airplanes.  The builder is
 responsible for certifying that the airplane is in compliance with
 the LSA requirements set forth by the FAA.  They are subject to
 usual Phase 1/2 flight testing.  They can be flown by anyone holding
 Sport Pilot privileges, just like any other LSA.  Being Experimental
 Amateur Built any modifications desired may be made, even if those
 changes would cause the airplane to no longer be in compliance with
 the LSA requirements set forth by the FAA.  Once the airplane is no
 longer in compliance with the LSA requirements the pilot must then
 hold a Private Pilot or Recreational Pilot certification to fly it.
 Once modified to be outside of the LSA definition it my NEVER be
 returned to LSA status even if the modifications are removed.  It
 will forever be EAB and cannot be flown by a person holding only
 Sport Pilot privileges.  EAB aircraft my not be used commercially or
 rented for any purpose.

 You can get flight training in your own EAB-LSA, or EAB, if you can
 get past the insurance hurdles and you can find a CFI willing to
 train you in your own aircraft.  You cannot use your own EAB-LSA or
 EAB aircraft to give flight training for compensation.

 If an LSA manufacturer chose to install a rotary engine, even with
 full FADEC controls, the FAA would have nothing to say about that.
 The manufacturer has to answer to the ASTM standard and certify that
 the aircraft design and fabrication are in compliance with the ASTM
 standard.

 Sorry for the long spew. ;-)

 Mark LaPierre

 "Dear Bill,

 Here's the reply regarding the Ae50. More to come

 "we are happy to hear you are aware of our aviation certified AE50R
 engine and also interested in it. In general the Schleicher dealer in
 USA is http://www.williamssoaring.com/ where Mr. Rex Mayes is the
 main contact person. He is also well known here at Austro Engine and
 you can buy a brand new engine also from him."


 Bill Rayfield

 Wow! Finally! this will help the rotary acceptance. If a few of these
 are sold maybe Austro will market their certified 110 HP two rotor
 version. Better for LSA.

 Paul Lamar


I've emailed the vendor and we will see what the response is.
I'm betting they are pricy and will not be a viable alternative for a
50hp engine class. Hopefully I will be proven wrong!

I would love a 65lb 55hp engine and no two stroke issues!
More to come

Bill Rayfield

It is fundamentally more efficient to pump fluid for a given cooling effect than to pump
air.  Quote Kays & London.

"The design of a heat exchanger involves a consideration of both the heat transfer rates between the fluids and the mechanical pumping power expended to overcome fluid friction and move the fluids through the heat exchanger. For a heat exchanger operating with high-density fluids, the friction-power expenditure is generally small relative to the heat transfer rate, with the result that the friction-power expenditure is seldom of controlling influence."

[What they are saying here is the HP consumed by the water pump is of minor importance. In fact the Mazda pump only consumes about 3 HP.]


"However, for low-density fluids, such as gases, it is very easy to expend as much mechanical energy in overcoming friction power as is transferred as heat."

[What is being said here is HP is consumed by cooling drag. Since cooling drag can be as high as 30% of over all drag the HP could be as much as 30% of 200 HP or 60 HP. As you can see cooling drag becomes a very important issue.]


If Austro replaced the rotor cooling air pump with our charge cooled  oil cooling
system it would reduce the fuel burn.  The same cooling passages are found in
the Austro end housings.

I should get a patent on that.

The BSFC on this engine is about .52. The current p-port Mazda is .47 leaned.

That is 10% increase  in fuel burn. Not significant for just putzing
around. A 50 HP aircraft is not something one would use to fly cross
country. With a head wind you might find your self flying backwards :-)

Paul Lamar

 The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
 the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
 site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
 Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.