Subject: One rotor E -shaft
From: paul lamar
Date: 9/29/2016, 7:04 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



I am thinking of machining a batch of one rotor e-shafts.

If your interested I will put you on the list.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want
off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL
web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide
rights reserved.


Hi Paul

What do you think of the one rotor package that Atkins Rotary are
offering.

Steve Burgess AU.

I don't know. I have not heard anything good or bad about it.

I also don't think it is p-ported, In that case it will be well under
100 HP. Could be as little as 75 HP.

A p-port is essential.

Of course if it does not have aluminum end housing it will
be very very heavy for 75 HP.  My guess is close to 200 pounds.

You can always add those features but at rather high cost and time.
The p-port might require a different carb or EFI system.


Paul Lamar




This would make the perfect engine for multitude of homebuilt projects, plans and kits out there.
I have been looking at the Zenith 750 STOL to build with my son in a couple of years (he is 6 now but would like to start when he is 8-9).

>From their Website,
"While all aircraft are designed within certain power and engine weight guidelines, Chris Heintz  has not designed the aircraft "around" a particular engine - to maximize the customer's choice of installed powerplant.  Recommended power for the STOL CH 750 (built to the Edition 2 <http://www.zenithair.com/news/750-gross-weight-increase.html <http://www.zenithair.com/news/750-gross-weight-increase.html> drawings) is 80 to 140 horsepower, up to 280 lbs. installed weight."

Their most popular engines being,
"


ULPower <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-ulpower.html <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-ulpower.html> (97 - 130 ho(hp)


Jabiru 3300 Engine <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-jabiru3300.html <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-jabiru3300.html> (105-hp @ 2950 rpm)


Continental O-200 <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-o-200-d.html <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-o-200-d.html> (100-hp)


Rotax 912ULS <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-rtx912s.html <http://www.zenithair.com/kit-data/zac-rtx912s.html> (100-hp)


Lycoming 233 LSA and O-235


Corvair auto conversion


Viking Honda conversion

"

For true 'stol' operations you would be looking for the lower end of the weight range and higher end of the power range they recommend.

So..... over 100hp in the 150-200lb range. (I still have difficulty comparing apples to onions, in regards to weights of all accessories, gear boxes, cooling etc....)

An Aluminum single rotor seems perfect for this (and many other planes) in regards to weight and power.
That leaves just two other variables, cost and ease.

It is my understanding that cost also tips in the favor of this option though maybe not as much as an optimist would claim when considering the Aluminum parts, gear box, and other 'little parts'.
Ease is what you are obviously working on with this newsgroup and educating people, but for most people, a more mainstream engine wins for availability of fwf kits and collective knowledge base.

Once I have started on the project, this is likely the engine I will chose. I hope that those who purchase these parts from you share regularly their journey to the air in order for those who follow (such as myself) can learn from their collective knowledge base. (the good, the bad, the ugly, all of it)

What I am trying to say is I love theory, I love dreaming, but I am really looking for as many real life examples as possible to learn from as well.


Narfi Willem

A two rotor is lower cost. We have several Zenair/Zenith  aircraft being powered by  two
rotors. You don't need aluminum end housings. The firewall forward weight is
no heaver than an O-320. The fuel burn per HP is the same.

Paul Lamar



The two rotor is highly available which means inexpensive. No machined one off e shaft. Also a two rotor runs very smoothly.

The one rotor has only one firing per revolution so runs like one of the old British 500 to 750cc one lungers commonly known as thumper. As the cylinder fires the block wants to turn the opposite direction causing a harmonic through the mounts. One way to counteract that is soft mounts so the vibration is not transfered.Vauxhaul on their 2.0 and 2.3L and Buick 225 and 231 engines used soft mounts for that reason.

With the 2 rotor and p port you can have about 230 to 250 HP available. That gives you great STOL characteristics and then cut power back to limit airspeed.
If you used a variable geometry turbo from a Porsche and a power recovery connected to the compressor side a bit more power could be had with better BSFC. Paul has written about this. With the variable geometry you would have increased torque even at low boost.
Dale Davies

They are not that bad. Most people who have them don't complain.

Paul Lamar

Is that the one rotor engine you are referring to? Being a somewhat low torque at lower RPM engine will negate the vibration from the firing pulse a bit. Running in aircraft at say 6000 RPM you should not feel any torque pulses.

Dale Davies

I think the inertia of the cast iron rotor and the counter weights mitigate the torque pulse.

Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,
for a single rotor engine, we would prefer Al end housings.  Racing Beat housings have a good name, can you give me a cost estimate and availability. RB will not respond to my emails.
Rs,
Dave Mccandless in Oz

Thats strange. I would think they would answer their email. Jim Medere owner never
answers mine either.  He has been sick lately. A lot of old guys I know never adapted to the
Internet. I just can't work with people that do not answer emails. The telephone is
no where near as effective as an email. You have a record of what is discussed.

And it is asynchronous and first in first out buffered. Not real time. A lot
of computer jargon there. It means you don't have to answer the phone
when your are busy and focused and you can handle the correspondence
when you get time.

Some times when I send an IGES they could at least say "OK" :-)

I think they don't bother to read their emails. Business is very marginally profitable
these days and one can't do business with out the Internet.

Now RB was charging about $1500 U.S. each. They work but they are not reflective
of the latest technology. Modified versions are used on the TTC engine.

I have tried to get some of my friends that own NC shops
interested but no luck so far. So I am planning on getting my NC Mill working and
making them myself. I will do away with side ports as they are not suitable for aircraft
use. That will greatly simplify them and do away with the need castings.

http://www.rotaryeng.net/Nc-Mill-How-To.html


Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.