Subject: Sachs rotary, charge cooled conversion starting Part 2
From: paul lamar
Date: 10/3/2016, 9:37 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



Hey Paul, ok so I took apart my second and third Sachs 293. One was
totally seized, the second was not but again inside was damaged as if
some type of debris found its way inside while the engine was running.

Now both of these have a super thin steel lining in the main block.
The end plates do not, all the end plates are just aluminum.

The seized engine the rotor was locked into place, basically I had to
beat the engine apart damaging a lot of parts. However there was so much
corrosion in the main housing the thin steel lining has come off in
places. The ballpark thickness is around .020, the thinnest was .014 and
the thickest was .032 .


So now we know lots of heads and complete engine blocks for piston
engines are aluminum, usually 356 alloy because of the high silicone
content that allows lapping it down to make a hard silica surface for
the rings and such to ride on. Some use high flame coatings that are
super hard. Some use Nikasil coating. In fact it was used by other auto
makers when developing their rotary engines instead of the steel liner
used by Mazda. It is a really hard coating but it can be expensive.

I do believe I will bit the bullet and have my new housing Nikasil
coated. Well, unless we can come up with something cheaper, that can
take the wear and the heat.

We could use a hard anodized finish for the side/end plates is we are
able to use the Teflon/carbon fiber side seals.

Now need to think of a material to use on the rotor apex seals that :

1- will  [not] dig into the aluminum housing

2- that will not gall the aluminum or weld the aluminum to the apex seal
itself.

3- that can withstand the combustion and exhaust port temperatures.

Now I do not remember where but I had seen a statement that the apex
seals perform really well at low speeds but are not a absolute necessity
at high speeds. If this is true then the seals could be a type of high
temp plastic that can withstand the pressure of combustion. One critical
thing that has to be thought about is the peak temp as the seal passes
the exhaust port and the flame passes a small portion of that apex seal
at 900 to 1200 degrees F. The exhaust port could span more of the
chamber but then you could get greater seal wear going over a long oval
port vs a rounder port.

If we have to make them from a high temp metal then we have to be very
careful of the seal shape to lessen the chance of galling or gouging the
aluminum housing. To me this would mean a wider seal face or less seal
pressure, or a combination of both.


David Mikesell

Fantastic information David thanks.

What are the dimensions of the Sach's Apex seals?

You might be able to use cut down 12A Mazda ceramic or cast iron seals.

That is REAL interesting about the thin steel liners.
That would be relatively easy to duplicate. They could be chrome plated
with out much cost. They are trapped in  there.  They could be hard
enough to act like a spring. Squeeze them in at the waist to install them.

Sort of snap in place. Small buttons, or tiny hills  would or could be
used to lock
them in place. This has some thermal heat loss advantages. The way Mazda
does it
is actually not as good thermally. Too much heat is transfered to the
aluminum.

Also long small diameter screws could be screwed in from the out side
into small metal bars
welded to the thin steel sheet around the hump area to hold them in place.

Kind of funny I did not know about that. Thin hard stainless steel might
work as well.
Even less heat transfer. Same for the side plates. Thin SS side plates
could be water
jet cut and be the cheese in the sandwich :-). Much much cheaper to repair.

Doing away with the charge cooling will improves the volumetric
efficiency up to 20 to
30% which translates to 20 to 30% more HP and a lower BSFC. We might
just come up with a world record low BSFC for all Wankel engines.

BSFC is pounds  of fuel burned for each HP generated.

Currently it is .47 for the leaned Mazda while a Lycoming is .45. The
Cont. engine
in my C182 is as bad as .52. If we can get it down to .46 that is a HUGE
reduction in
the history of rotary BSFC's.

Currently the BSFC for an air cooled Austro Engines one rotor is .52 to
.55.
Higher for all charged cooled engines. Over .6x for the OMC's.

All turbo props are over .65 and as bad as 1.0 !!!!

Seems the thermal heat loss thing was the last thing on Kenichi
Yamamoto  mind
when he designed the Mazda. He just wanted it to work.


Paul Lamar

I gave some thought to a steel liner too, chrome plating would be great for a low friction surface. How to bond it into place would be hard. In the seized engine, it looks like it was full of water for a while so alot of the aluminum suffered from galvanic corrosion due to the steel liner. Where the liner was still in place it was really hard to break it free. The outside surface of the steel looks like it may have been textured and then bonded in place with the aluminum housing heated to allow insertion of the liner. Just a guess.

I had thought about using .020 SS for a housing liner. Welding the ends together of the sheet would be pretty dicey, I would be afraid from heat and stress the weld would fail. Getting it to stay in place would be pretty difficult. If we were to weld steel bars across the width and use external screws to pull the liner into place would require quite a few, at least one every 1 to 1.5 inches to give the liner the support it would need to be rigid against the rotors movement. This would create another problem. I flat spot that would be at every bar, the width would depend on the bars width, it would need to be ground and polished into shape. Lots more money and time.

So if we went with a thicker sheet, it could be say .050 to .060. That is thick enough to be rolled shaped. Plus a lot better to have the ends welded and not worry so much about the weld snapping from heat and pressure. Now to figure out the best place to put the edge seam to create the least amount of fatigue on the weld. Probably at one end in the big radius. I think with the thicker sheet, small .035 strips could be welded on the outside of the ss liner across the width. With matching slots in the aluminum housing. The housing would then be heated in a oven to expand. Then the liner chilled and coated with a high temp locking compound, then press the liner into the hot housing and let it cool. That should lock the liner in place, The only thing I worry about is the expansion rate might not be high enough with the ss to allow the engine to come up to temperature and give adequate rotor clearance.

These are the reason I thought of just getting the main housing treated with Nikasil. BFSC would about the same as most rotary's. It would make the milling of the main housing and both end plates pretty easy. Basically I want the engine build to be possible by most builders who have access to a small cnc mill, or to a tech shop or cnc college course that has at least a Tomach or a Haas Mini Mill. Even possible for someone with a small mill they converted to cnc in their own little shop.  With the e-shaft and rotor coming from a used/old OMC or Sachs engine sitting in a sled junk yard somewhere.

I want this to be as easy and as inexpensive as possible.


David Mikesell


 The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.