Subject: Laser metal sintering of rotary housing
From: paul lamar
Date: 12/4/2016, 4:35 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



I came across this picture in a design guide brochure for a 3D
printing service (Xometry). Immediately recognized the trochoid shape
with cooling chambers. I was going to inquire about the cost of the
part and whether dissimiliar metals can be combined in one cohesive
part. Anyone in the rotary group recognize it as their own? Daniel
Tyler Inline image 1



Could they be making the part in wax or low temp plastic then casting
the housing?  Wouldn't the housing be stronger if ot were cut from
billet? (Using  a water jet cutter to avoid heating the metal ?


Rob Miller

Paul, Rob, I have done a lot of research on the DMLS process. This is
not wax! This is directly FUSED metal. The resulting solid is
generally as good as billet material. This additive process uses the
laser to melt the layers together. many exotic materials are
available. The earliest use I saw of this technology was it make new
shape jet engine compressor blades. This is a very highly stressed
part and the DMLS process was making a nearly finished shape. Very
little post machining. The price varies based on how exact you want
the part and the finish. If you want a very good surface the layers
must be very thin and the laser time will be high. If you can deal
with a fairly rough surface say +-.010-.015 it is considerably
cheaper. That rotor housing would require inside finishing and
coating, but the outside could be left as is. The water passages
might even benefit by having more surface area.

Bill Jepson

For turbine parts the material machining can be very expensive. If
the original construction is very accurate there is almost no
machining. Dale Davies

According to someone I know who purchased a Lasertec DMLS a couple of
years ago from DMG Mori, the in-layer strength of DMLS is about equal
to a forged part.  The between-layer strength is about like a cast
part.  One big feature, aside from the ability to make quick
corrections in a model and then turn out an improved prototype, is
the ability to mix metals fairly freely within the part.

The side housing in the photo would be extremely expensive, even if
one owned a DMLS, because of the high cost of the powdered metal. A
casting would be much cheaper.

GE is now transitioning to ceramic matrix composites for their
turbine blades.  As the price comes down for CMCs, I expect to see
them in a lot of applications, including automobile and aircraft
reciprocating engines.  CMCs would be perfect for rotary engines, but
right now the price is just too high.

Dave Klingler

RE: heat transfer. in W/mK  at about 68°F. Pure Al 204
Gray cast Fe 47 -80 Stainless Steel  12 - 45 Ti
19 - 23 That puts Ti right in the middle of stainless steels and less
than cast iron.

Dale Davies

One can make a 3D printer with a stick welder and an NC mill. As I
under stand it the laser versions use metal powder that cost a lot. A
stick welder would be cheap.

It would not be as accurate as a laser 3D printer but one could then
machine it to final dimensions.

PauL Lamar


   It would be very difficult to control the Z dimension of the work piece
   as the welding rod burned away while the layer was being laid down. You
   would also have the issue of having to stop frequently to insert a new
   welding rod every minute of so.

   I could see this concept working better with MIG or automated TIG welding.

   Could you explain what your concept is and how it would work? Perhaps
   my mental image differs from your idea.


Mark LaPierre


   I should have said wire feed.

   For tig welding one needs to add an automatic device to feed in the wire.

   What would be ideal is a 5 axis NC mill and then the gravity vector could be
   made to always point down.

   These oil pans were mostly  tig welded with  an automatic tig welder I invented.
   There was no need for rod when the joint type was properly chosen.

   The torch was stationary and the pan moved under the torch. No time
   was saved but there was no need for a highly skilled tig welding worker
   ether. The details were welded by such a person.

   The key is to measure the metal temperature just ahead of the weld and control
   the weld current based on that.

   Just another one of my many inventions. I need a full time patent lawyer :-)

   Paul Lamar

   TIG welding process can also be used with automated wire feed.

   Steve Carlisle

   The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
   the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
   site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
   Copyright 1998-2016 All world wide rights reserved.