Subject: what is the best way to do this. Machining problem
From: paul lamar
Date: 2/6/2017, 2:47 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



I have the steady rest frame bolted to my rotary table.

I have two roughing end mills. The big one shown
and some 3/8 on the way. I broke a 5/16th already.

Roughly speaking, is it better to run the cutter at high RPM
when cutting these sever discontinuities or low RPM?

Big cutter or small cutter?

I would like to keep the chatter down.

Paul Lamar



Since this is such a big opening, I suggest you go with a tool no
smaller than .75
Two or Four flute will work, Spindle RPM is figured by this formula:

RPM = (3.82 X SFPM) / Dia (for ball part Rpm's)

Depending on the steel you are using, for 1020/1040/1018 I use 100 for
the SFPM


so if you go by using a .75 tool,  3.82 x 100=382/.75= 509 Rpm's

Here are the basic formulas, they work so use them.

RPM = (3.82 x SFPM) / Dia
SFPM = (RPM X Dia) / 3.82
CL = IPM / (N x RPM)
IPM = CL x N x RPM
IPM = IPR X RPM
RPM reamer = 50%
RPM corner radius cutter = 33%
RPM chamfer cutter = 33%

works for lathes or mills

Now if you want to be exact then you get the chipload info from the
manufacture and use the CL formula

Oh and I do highly recommend a Machinist Calculator, has all the built
in formulas and more. The ones I have in my shop are called
the Machinist Calc Pro....I think it was $80, I have four of them, one
at each machine and I love them.


For what you are doing this is fine. For a cutter I recommend a .75
cutter by Niagra, here is the link to that cutter at MSC

https://www.mscdirect.com/browse/tn/Milling/Square-End-Mills?searchterm=niagra&navid=4287924598#navid=4287924598+4288247917+4288247595+4288247839&searchterm=niagra
<https://www.mscdirect.com/browse/tn/Milling/Square-End-Mills?searchterm=niagra&navid=4287924598#navid=4287924598+4288247917+4288247595&searchterm=niagra>



I know alot of people will say 4 flute for steel, but two flute will
work fine, alot will say get a carbide mill, also a mistake, it will
chip in the manual mill (you have to have almost 0 play/backlash to keep
from chipping your carbide mill bit)

After I got our of school for machining, I did what most people do,
followed what I was told in school. Luckily my good friend I made in
school, his dad owns a machine shop that rebuilds pumps and electric
motors. I don;'t mean little ones either these are extremely large. He
also owns the largest dynamic spin balancer in Northern California.

I was lucky enough to get to hang out and learn from this man who built
his shop from nothing to a very successful shop that is always slammed
with work. I also help out by taking care of their CNC machines. Anyway
he changed the way I was taught and think about cutting steel. His way
works, I ruin less tools and get a much longer tool life. Experience
counts and his is alot of great experience.

David Mikesell
San Jose, CA


Thanks David. It is a real old CC mill drill the  RPM goes from 230 to
2120 RPM.

I have a one inch 4 flute cutter in there now.

Material is cold rolled steel .75 inch high(thick).

So I will keep it on the slow side. No real cooling. Not like an NC in a
sealed  cabinet :-)

I will work on building a cabinet for the Kasuga.
It has cooling system but the entire shop gets wet :-)


Paul Lamar

Glad to hear it is 1 inch. I always go as big as I can when hogging out big holes.

I work on my manual mills all the time, I have a oil can filled with cutting oil I use when cutting, one is for steel and one is for aluminum.

for a 1 inch tool with a normal chip load I would say 350 to 380 would be the right rpm for that tool and material.

David M.
San Jose,CA


It is working pretty good and I have some more T nuts coming for the Palmgren rotary table.

A little more rigidity :-)


Paul Lamar




The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net <http://www.rotaryeng.net/>You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.