Subject: RD-1c question Tracy Responds
From: paul lamar
Date: 3/11/2017, 8:23 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



 Paul, do you or anyone on the group remember the change in
 crankshaft resistance after torquing down the RD 1C 12" an4 bolts
 at final assembly?

 The assembly instructions show a trial fitting without the 5 1/8
 inch ring gear spacer o-ring. This worked well on my unit, with
 the crankshaft turning easily by hand.  However I found this "O"
 ring was missing from my unit.

 Tracy's specifications are for a 5 1/8 inch outside diameter and
 0.190 inch thickness, which  corresponds to an AS568-351 (3/16"
 thick). I ordered some of these,  but found that the actual
 thickness is 0.21 inches, not 0.190". I cannot find any metric or
 other equivalent size that exactly matches the 0.190
 specification.

 When tightening down the drive bolts to the final torque, the
 resistance to turn the crank shaft roughly doubled. I can still
 detect just a little bit of backlash play, but the torque required
 to turn the crank shaft without spark plugs installed is
 approximately 20 foot pounds.  It appears this is due to the
 resistance of the ring gear pressing on the O-ring against the
 adapter housing.

 Does anyone know if this amount of resistance is normal, or
 perhaps Tracy was using some o-rings that are exactly 0.190 inches
 in thickness?

 Thanks!

 Scott Gettings


 I assume that is the late  one that does away with the torque
 damper. I have no experience with that one. Send me a dwg or
 sketch if you can. A picture or two would also help.

 Typical of O-ring dimensions. It gets real critical when you are
 dealing with the rotor housing O-rings. Too big and it will crack
 the cast iron.

 I this case it's not that bad.

 Paul Lamar


 The RD1 C still has the 4-bolt damper that mounts to the flex
 plate. I added AN 970 large washers to the bolts on the engine side
 to the plate, which was obviously highly stressed by the bolts and
 standard washers on that side. It is also easy to inspect.

 I have attached the expanded view of the RD1-C.  The ring gear has
 a 45 degree cut on the outer circumference to accept the o-ring.
 The oring just pushes against the solid adapter cylinder (the part
 that bolts directly to the adapter plate), thus keeping the ring
 gear tight.  It seems this oring spins against one or the other
 surface when running.  So when trial assembling without the oring,
 the gears spin freely.  With the oring in place, there is pressure
 on the ring gear as the bolts torque down.

 Here is the scan and adapter pix.

 Thanks, Scott Gettings


 The ring gear is stationary. The bulkhead the ring gear splines on
 is bolted to the gear box case. Nothing critical about that O
 ring.

 Those bolts are flat heads screws. The early ones where known to
 shear. I think the diameter was increased in the later versions.

 The stock Ford bulkhead is powdered metal and SUPER hard. Makes a
 good bolt shear :-)

 Old message:

 "I found that seven (7) of the eight (8) 1/4-20 bolts holding the
 ring gear to the casting were broken.  Only one bolt was still in
 tact, and it was loose.  After discussing this with Tracy, we
 agreed to drill and tap them to 5/16-20 which I did. "

 Please take one of those screws out an measure the diameter for
 me.

 After you fly it for a few hours  it disassemble the gear box and
 check those bolts that bolt the ring gear bulkhead to the gear box
 case.

 Paul Lamar



 Will do.

 Scott Gettings

 Paul,

 I opened my RD1-C drive, and have included some pix.  The ring gear
 is on a splined shaft connected directly to the prop hub.  It is
 not fixed to the case and does not have  the  screws mentioned
 above. The ring gear can easily be pulled out, as per the pic.  The
 planet carrier is fixed to the “spacer” part of the RD case
 (against the flat adapter plate).

 You can see the location of the o-ring.  When in place, it sticks
 up about 0.03” before compression.  Since the surface on the
 spacer/planet carrier where the o-ring contacts is rough (see pic)
 , it appears that the ring gear must rotate along the fixed o-ring
 surface.  There is nothing else other  than the o-ring holding the
 ring gear from impacting the  prop side of the  planet carrier.

 Turning the engine over without compression requires about 10 ft-lb
 of torque.  When the  o-ring is compressed, this doubles to about
 20 ft-lbs.  Do you think this is an acceptable amount of drag?

 Thanks again?

 Scott Gettings


 Aw so my mistake. I thought all C versions were 3.12 to one. You
 have a 2.12 to one I think. Power is out of the ring gear rather
 than the planet carrier as in a 3-2-1.

 An O-ring used in that fashion is very very unusual to say the
 least. That is not what they are designed for.

 Maybe Tracy did that to dampen some vibrations. I have NO idea what
 he was thinking :-)

 Paul Lamar


 Paul, Sent this question to Tracy and his reply is below........

 Tracy, The post below was sent to Paul Lamar by Scott
 Gettings.........Perhaps you can shine some light on his problem
 ??............I was not aware the "O" ring was used on the 2.17
 version of your redrive...........The initial thought was Scott's
 redrive is a RD1C but photos show it to be a RD1B........If you do
 not have Scott's E mail send your response to me and I will forward
 it.........Thanks

 Best Regards,

 Kelly Troyer


 Kelly Troyer

 You are right Kelly, the RD-1B does not use that O-ring.  That’s
 only for the -1C version.   Not surprised the drive would bind if
 he tried to use one on a B.

 All the best, Tracy

 Paul, if I drill and tap 5/16x20. What kind of screws should I use
 (strength wise) not a standard aircraft thread. Was the engine that
 had the box with sheared screws stock,blown pp or what. Has anyone
 else experienced screw shear?

 Thanks

 Rich Goldman

Aw so you have one. The threads have nothing to do with it.
Alloy Steel Hex Drive Flat Head Screws from macmaster carr are the best.

That powdered metal bulkhead is the real problem. Hit it with a hammer
and it will fracture. In any  bolted shear joint there are microscopic changes
in both materials in the vicinity of the surface of the bolt. NOTHING is perfectly
rigid!!!!! The softer material will take the brunt of this defection so that is the
start of the shearing action. The bolt has the highest contact stress so that fails.

Leave them in there or take them  out but put some extended point set screws
around the out side of the ring gear. There is literally room for a thousand.

Chris Hoskins in NZ may have some pictures of the out side of his gear
box with these set  screws installed. At least some pictures of the drilled
ring gear I hope. Not deep enough to affect the gear mesh.

 If the ring gear is a loose fit in the housing coat it with
red RTV and try and center it in the housing. Use narrow spacers and withdraw
them after the RTV cures. It does not have to be perfect. Red RTV is
good to 500 F. Planetaries are self centering due to the gear engagement loads.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.