Hi Paul; If you're looking at doing rotor & efficiency mods -
Take another look at the SAE841017 - recent 84 tech pg 6, Fig 14,13,20,
note very low BSFC @ 7500rpm in fig.14 for the large pport.
And the 81RE-KY bible p.48-49-53 LDR/MDR/L-flat charts for BSFC/MEP
improvements.
Cheers Cary Beazley
The 81RE-Ken Yamamoto bible p.48-49-53 LDR/MDR/L-flat charts for
BSFC/MEP improvements are within the margin of measurement
error IMHO. Notice the RX 8 used neither :-) The bathtub is
symmetrical and wider. Here is the combust data out of the 84 paper.
It implies there is a difference in pressure at the spark plug holes !!!!!!!
If the pressure is not equal the force vector is deflected. More data is
needed with more pressure sensors. One every 1/4 inch or even 1 every
1/2 inch.
More work needs to be done on the bath tubs.
And the wind problem.
Paul Lamar
Yep, may very well be measurement or calibration error - definitely a
difference between the the 81 bible and 84 tech papers, & CW papers.
Fully agree on the need for more research and maybe see the latest
direct injection and ignition research.
I would argue the rx8 side port configuration might have been chosen
more to reduce emissions with more focus on low-mid power drive-ability.
I'm still looking for an old chart showing the BSFC/BMEP due to side
port turbulence swirl.
Cary Beazley
Well I got my Rhino up and running and drew some rotors.
I was amazed again at a small difference in the location of the center
of the pressure
vector relative to the center of the rotor surface made so much
difference in
the torque generated.
One reason for this is the extremely short stroke of the e-shaft.
If the center of pressure is off by as little as an inch a large
difference in the amount of torque generated when the e-shaft
is 90 degrees beyond TDC and the rotor has rotated 30 degrees.
There is also a torque on the rotor about it's center reacted by the
stationary gear.
The e-shaft moment arm drastically changes.
The very best configuration is move the center of pressure as
far upstream or aft as you far as you can get it.
Given the geometry it is amazing
the Wankel is so close to the piston engine.
Paul Lamar
Hi!: thanks for the very good image 'breakthrough..', that I don't catch
in full, but a doubt comes to my mind, if the space above the Rotor
surface is continuous, i.e, having no walls, pressure applied to rotor
surface must have no major differences from leading area to training
side, as the pressure is transmitted uniformly through a gas.
Are there any experimental measurements in the line of local pressure
and torque to shaft differences according to recess type?
Thanks, regards, Salut †
Jose Gros-AymerichMadrid, Spain
That is not true when there is motion involved. Just like an airplane flying
in a large sealed hangar. In this case there is dynamic pressure in front
of the advancing trailing apex seal. When the top surface of the rotor
approaches the inner surface of the rotor housing, at high speed, a
strong airflow
is generated and moves forward increase the air pressure in the leading
part of the moving combustion chamber.
Since the air velocities involved are quite high at about 200 MPH the
dynamic pressure can be as much as 100 pounds per square foot or .7 psi.
Perhaps more.
Thanks for bring that up. It is called dynamic pressure.
Paul Lamar
Paul and All,
If you look at Paul's figure on trailing and middle depression rotor
faces you notice the peaks are different.
There is a squish peak at 30 deg ATDC which I think is what Paul is
worried about.
This middle pocket is the one Mazda uses so the data from my combustion
studies become relevant.
If we examine the "Max rate of combustion" it shows that squish increase
helps and the its peak speed of increase is at 30 deg.
Probably why Mazda chose to use it.
See attached
Barry Bordes
Maybe they were not thinking about what affect that had on the center of
pressure.
Paul Lamar
OK Paul bear with me,
To summarize we would like to keep the flame burning and the center of
pressure toward the trailing side? If that is true the recess on the MB
C111 Wankel looks perfect. I have long been mentioning that all the way
back to the flathead Ford V8's they knew that the flame goes out when
the clearance between the parts is less than approximately .010-.015
inches. The MB rotor keeps the recess shallower but extends almost all
the way to the trailing apex seal. I mentioned this before. I may not be
seeing the whole picture, if so, please let me know what I am missing.
Bill Jepson
I think you understand the problem but I don't recall seeing that rotor
recess shape
in the Mercedes pictures I have. It was opposite to that.
Here is what I have.
I think we can get high speed pressure sensors and drill a bunch of tiny
holes in the rotor
housing to get a pressure profile when the engine is running at all
e-shaft angles
around TDC. The pressure sensors shown are good to 2000 CPS and
4000500 or more psi.
I don't think the CFD's so far have dealt with dynamic pressure.
This is the only thing that differentiates the Wankel combustion chamber
from
the piston engine combustion chamber. IMHO it is the main reason for the
slightly worse Wankel BSFC. Yes there are some heat loss issues as well but
they can be dealt with separately.
Here is the CFD results on wind speed in the combustion chamber.
Obviously it does not consider boundary layer effects and dynamic pressure
effects. The numbers like 180 Meters per second or about 500 MPH
are extraordinary nevertheless. At 500 MPH one can get some very
significant dynamic pressures. The torque you get has a lot to
due to were the center of pressure is located on the rotor face.
The dual plugs are too far downstream IMHO. Not a good place to
generate instantaneous pressure. Dual side by side plugs are great
but perhaps there should be four.
These TE pressure sensors are only $18 and they go up to 4300 psi.
With six or eight we would get a good pressure profile. they have a
2000 CPS responses.
I think we could log the data with one or two Maximites.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you. ACRE NL web
site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.