Subject: All you guys wanting gear boxes
From: paul lamar
Date: 6/14/2017, 10:39 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink




What EFI or carb are you planning on using?

Paul Lamar


I have been planning on using Tracy's at this point (purchased
years ago), but would love to have another, more practical EFI
solution that does not involve detailed programming.

Scott Gettings


How close are you to running Scott ?

I would write the program and build the injection hardware.

Are you willing to use an M&W CD ignition?

That greatly simplifies the hardware and software.

Paul

Most likely yes.   I purchased Tracy's EFI but have no problem
replacing it with another, more practical alternative.  Will M&W
allow using the stock injectors and coils?

My fuel system is otherwise done.   My plan is to finalize all the
components and wring out the entire pusher configuration in an
airboat.  This will avoid having too many new systems to deal with
in flight testing.

I'm still searching for the best radiator cores to weld into a
folded, cross counterflow unit (4 total of about 15x20x1").  I
think the best oil cooler option (considering all your
input--thanks!!) is two, appx 5x20x2" units in the lower, rear
cowl, fed by under-wing ducts blending into K&L diffusers and exit
ducts ending in front of the pusher prop to assure low pressure.
The other options have structural issues that prevent their
implementation.

So, I think I'm 90% done, but also unfortunately have 90% to go
:-)

Scott Gettings

M&W has absolutely nothing to do with the injection system. It does
ignition only.

However Tracy's and most other system uses stock inductive coils.
This requires the injection system computer to calculate the
correct time to turn the coils on and off when the spark occurs.

Take that software out of the EFI system and it becomes much
simpler to control just the injection. A slower, much easier to
program, computer will now do the injection work. If one is used
per rotor that is even less work for the software.

The software can now act as a black box and record all the engine
parameter as often as ten times a second. Of course if one computer
fails the engine will still run on the other. The reliability is
going to depend on how good the wire connections are made.

Paul Lamar

Are the main reasons not to use any of the aftermarket / racing
controllers the cost ($1-1.5K) and lack of altitude compensation?

I suspect that many builders (myself included) are limited in our
ability to design, build and/or program such devices and will need as
much of a plug and play environment as possible.  Many of us were
hoping for that with Tracy's EFI/ignition controller.  I for one
would would be willing to pay much more to avoid months or years of
struggling with systems or devices  that I would not be able to
manage.

Scott Gettings


This is flippant but if it is open loop you will spend a lot of time
tuning it. Welcome to the world of EFI. Motec cost $3000 and
you need a masters degree in EFI to tune that. We spent a whole
year on it with the TTC and hired a experienced tech and payed him $75 an hour.

I would have been able to do it if Motec had good beginner documentation
but they don't. This is one of the top systems in the world.

There is a rumor that Motec can work closed loop on just the O2 sensor but
so far that is unconfirmed.

I suspect the Megasquirt PC tuning software may be  one of the best as it has been
in development for at least 15 Years.

I am having trouble with my ISP right at the moment. They are working
on it so my response may be slow for a few days.

Paul Lamar

   A possible way to EFI on the cheap would be:

   1: Take two complete throttle body systems off an early model such as the Chev Celebrity, Dodge Omni or Ford Topaz. If using auto fuel, use a Premium fuel without alcohol in it. The two throttle bodies would work like two Ellisons. Carb heat required.

   2: Take one throttle body system off a 350 or 454 truck. Kind of like the two barrel Holley.
   With O2 sensors, both work closed loop. Just the problem of leaning to work out.

   Dale Davies

Megasquirt open source EFI seems to have matured enough to be a contender. Matt Boiteau has his p-port running on the megasquirt and so far he likes it.

I have Tracy's ec2 with software upgrades for my non p-port Renesis setup. When I had my ec2 software updated a few years back Tracy said he had refined the baseline map to a point where it should work with most renesis installations out the box, with minimal tuning. For anyone holding one of the older RWS units it might be worth the money to send it to Tracy for the latest upgrade. The cost was 50 or 100 USD, I can't remember exactly

Alex Molteno

Is Megasquirt closed now?

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.