Subject: All you guys wanting gear boxes
From: paul lamar
Date: 6/16/2017, 8:02 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


What EFI or carb are you planning on using?

Paul Lamar


I have been planning on using Tracy's at this point (purchased years
ago), but would love to have another, more practical EFI solution
that does not involve detailed programming.

Scott Gettings


How close are you to running Scott ?

I would write the program and build the injection hardware.

Are you willing to use an M&W CD ignition?

That greatly simplifies the hardware and software.

Paul

Most likely yes.   I purchased Tracy's EFI but have no problem
replacing it with another, more practical alternative.  Will M&W
allow using the stock injectors and coils?

My fuel system is otherwise done.   My plan is to finalize all the
components and wring out the entire pusher configuration in an
airboat.  This will avoid having too many new systems to deal with
in flight testing.

I'm still searching for the best radiator cores to weld into a
folded, cross counterflow unit (4 total of about 15x20x1").  I think
the best oil cooler option (considering all your input--thanks!!) is
two, appx 5x20x2" units in the lower, rear cowl, fed by under-wing
ducts blending into K&L diffusers and exit ducts ending in front of
the pusher prop to assure low pressure. The other options have
structural issues that prevent their implementation.

So, I think I'm 90% done, but also unfortunately have 90% to go :-)

Scott Gettings

M&W has absolutely nothing to do with the injection system. It does
ignition only.

However Tracy's and most other system uses stock inductive coils.
This requires the injection system computer to calculate the correct
time to turn the coils on and off when the spark occurs.

Take that software out of the EFI system and it becomes much simpler
to control just the injection. A slower, much easier to program,
computer will now do the injection work. If one is used per rotor
that is even less work for the software.

The software can now act as a black box and record all the engine
parameter as often as ten times a second. Of course if one computer
fails the engine will still run on the other. The reliability is
going to depend on how good the wire connections are made.

Paul Lamar

Are the main reasons not to use any of the aftermarket / racing
controllers the cost ($1-1.5K) and lack of altitude compensation?

I suspect that many builders (myself included) are limited in our
ability to design, build and/or program such devices and will need as
much of a plug and play environment as possible.  Many of us were
hoping for that with Tracy's EFI/ignition controller.  I for one
would would be willing to pay much more to avoid months or years of
struggling with systems or devices  that I would not be able to
manage.

Scott Gettings


This is flippant but if it is open loop you will spend a lot of time
tuning it. Welcome to the world of EFI. Motec cost $3000 and you
need a masters degree in EFI to tune that. We spent a whole year on
it with the TTC and hired a experienced tech and payed him $75 an
hour.

I would have been able to do it if Motec had good beginner
documentation but they don't. This is one of the top systems in the
world.

There is a rumor that Motec can work closed loop on just the O2
sensor but so far that is unconfirmed.

I suspect the Megasquirt PC tuning software may be  one of the best
as it has been in development for at least 15 Years.

I am having trouble with my ISP right at the moment. They are working
on it so my response may be slow for a few days.

Paul Lamar

A possible way to EFI on the cheap would be:

1: Take two complete throttle body systems off an early model such as
the Chev Celebrity, Dodge Omni or Ford Topaz. If using auto fuel, use
a Premium fuel without alcohol in it. The two throttle bodies would
work like two Ellisons. Carb heat required.

2: Take one throttle body system off a 350 or 454 truck. Kind of like
the two barrel Holley. With O2 sensors, both work closed loop. Just
the problem of leaning to work out.

Dale Davies

Like Scott mentioned, many of us don't have the skill set to design
and build an EI/EFI ourself. I have been reading up on the Fueltech
FT 500 system.  They specifically mention its use on Rotary Engines
and they strongly advertise its easy method of configuration using
its built in touch screen display.  Has anyone else seen or heard of
this system or have any knowledge of its ease of setup?

Don Mitchell

I think you are in for a little surprise unless it is closed loop. A
car engine is nothing like an aircraft engine.

Paul Lamar



Thanks Paul, and I'm sorry if that was a dumb question regarding the
Fueltech System.  But aren't all of these systems designed for cars?
Maybe I missed something in the years of following intermittently,
but I was under the impression that only Tracy designed (and made
available) an EI/EFI

System specifically for Rotary Aviation use.  I realize that an
aircraft engine application is extremely different from that of a
car, But since all of these currently available systems are built for
cars it will require some reprogramming of any of them to make them
suitable for aviation use.

Was just hoping to hear from anyone who might have any first hand
knowledge from working with a Fueltech System.

In October 2015, Simon Saba posted some comments about and I have
been curious since that time. Thanks again, Don Mitchell

Yes they are.  The problem the way they were designed.  Up until
recently when Bosch improved the O2 sensor they all used the fuel
table method. If you are a car manufacturer it is no problem after
you tune it with the trial an error method because all the car engine
of that make and model will be the same.

Take it out of a car in put it in an aircraft you you have to start
over tuning it with the trial an error method.  If it was designed
for a rotary with a side port and a given intake manifold and you try
to use it with a p-port start over on the tuning. If some one claims
it is easy ask what intake manifold and what kind of ports it was
tuned for. Also ask if a mixture table is involved.

If you can find one that has flown on a rotary with the same kinds of
ports. You have a good change of being in the tuning ball park.
Differences in drag and the prop diameter pitch and gear box ratio
are also important.

The new Bosch LSU 4 O2 sensor in theory can be used in a closed loop
feed back system and tuning is then automatic. Not only that the
software is trivial compared to the mixture table method.

Paul Lamar

Hi, Engines have no idea of what kind of vehicle they are in or not
in, say running on a dyno. Tuning an engine involves finding the
mixture and ignition timing for best power or economy or smog
depending what conditions of rpm and load you are going to operate.
Tuning for prop load is more straight forward than for auto use. Does
not the MAP sensor give the ECU enough info for altitude compensation
or is another pressure sensor required.


Lamda sensors make tuning much easier as does a dyno.  A controllable
pitch prop is a good way to test an engine and be able to vary the
load for tuning purposes. It will not give you the numbers unless it
is set up as a torque stand. Murry Rozansky

The MAP sensor is not enough. If that were true one could run it
closed loop. Other adjustments must be made that is the reason for
the mixture table.

Paul Lamar


I noticed that the mega squirt systems have altitude correction available
which could be really helpful.

Don Mitchell

In a closed loop system that is done automatically.

If one accepts that the closed loop system works
all the work done and recorded by Megasquirt in the last 15 years is
now obsolete and  useless. Imagine how a programmer would feel
when told the several thousand hours he had invested in
the MegaSquirt software was now of no value. He would fight the closed loop
system and deny that  it worked.

All the R&D done in WW I on rotary radial engines was obsoleted
in the space of one year when it was discovered that the aerodynamic
drag of the rotating cylinders was subtracting from the net HP out.

New inventions tend to to that.

Paul Lamar


The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.