Subject: Lanair is not a certified aircraft 12 f
From: paul lamar
Date: 11/11/2017, 5:15 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink





12 f
Lycoming iE2

https://www.lycoming.com/engines/ie2 <https://www.lycoming.com/engines/ie2>

"Cruise at a set RPM and correct your air and fuel mixture with a
single lever. Our single-lever controls allow you manage your mixture
control and propeller control electronically so you can focus on
what's ahead. The iE2 engine uses optimized and automatic fuel
leaning for improved fuel efficiency during takeoff, climb and
cruise."

- Matt Boiteau

Its an experimental home built.

Good idea of Lycoming. Selling a non certified aircraft engine.

Experimental home built's are 30 to 40 % of the market.

Paul Lamar



Yeah I talked to the lycoming rep I think it was at Oshkosh and they
said there plan is to get it certified as well and sell it for both
experimental and certified aircraft. It's a pretty sophisticated
system I talked to mt buddy Kevin Eldridge that works for lancair at
reno and he said its doing pretty good.

Jacob Sturges



Its been doing good for years. The FAA has a problem. How is an IA
going to check it out? Where are they going to find IA's that know
about computers.

Paul Lamar


           the website doesn’t say what the engine costs….what does it cost?…further is it more expensive than a fully modified turbo 13b…..just because it isn’t liquid cooled why would i want one? What is the operating cost per hour?  An O320 is $100 per hour….is that what you really want to pay going forward…a 13b isn’t nearly that cost.
           Byron Head



I am all for engine conversions, rotarys, efi, ect. It breeds innovation and is great for aviation.  There are plenty of reasons to do a engine conversion, horsepower, cool factor, r&d for a turn key set up to maybe bring the cost down by semi mass production, and plus its just fun, but the reality is cost is not it. Let's be realistic a rotary conversion is not cheaper than a o-320 as much as I like it and wish it was it's not.

       The initial cost is almost always higher than buying a used low time lycoming, most private pilots will never fly enough hours for the rotary to pay for itself, and not to mention if your time is worth anything you will have 5 times the amount of labor in it and trial and error than you would in a lycoming, not that that's not fun that's why I love experimental aviation.


       I am all for it and want to do one myself  but saving money is not the reason for it, I bet no one can show me  a price breakdown that proves this wrong.  Being experimental a person can build a experimental 320 pretty darn cheap. I am excited about everything you all are doing and love seeing the rotarys fly, but in my opinion the development stage they are currently in,  is not a more cost effective alternative for the average pilot. Hopefully with all the work you all are doing that could change soon.
       Thanks, Jacob Sturgis

       You better take it apart and magnaflux the crank and rods.
       My 1500 hour O-470 crank was a mass of cracks.

       Even if it has been overhauled you could get a new crack at any time.
       The only really safe think is new cranks and rods.

       Paul Lamar

   OK, now look at the late 19th century and very early 20th century. Small reciprocating engines were being developed. What was the cost of development then compared to a horse and carriage? Same thing, different era. Recip engines have about 150 years of development behind them. Care to estimate man hours studying and developing them.


   Many manufacturers stepped up in the 1960's to investigate and develop rotary engines. One by one they fell by the wayside except little Toyo Kogyo Motors. At this time there is about 60 years development and compared to recip engines, minimal man hours doing R&D. After all those manhours of recip R&D they still break crankshafts and conn rods. Mazda has had no e-shaft structural failures to date. Failures have been due to oiling issues or over rev which causes oiling issues.

   Dale Davies



        The topic was cost not reliability,  I just said there's tons of reasons to go for a rotary and I am with everyone on that, its just cost is not one of them and that's not a huge deal for everyone I would be willing to pay more, not everyone in aviation is trying to save every penny, and if they are from my experience there playing in the wrong field. It can be done on a budget but all it takes is one problem to wipe your budget out.

      I think a lot of you guys defiantly have the brains for it and have all ready designed and flown plenty of viable engine packages I just think in order to get the cost down cheaper than a lycoming, someone would need to be producing the parts like, intake, ecu, gearbox, engine mounts, ect all the things you guys designed yourself, in large enough batches  to get the cost down and the labor down for the average builder to get more in the sky's. I know that takes a large investment, money and time  and like you said the piston engine has alot more behind it, so I  imangine its tough to find the big funding needed to get a streamlined engine package. I just think there is a lot  more people that would run a rotary but are too overwhelmed or lack some of the knowledge to do it on there own. Let me be clear I am not against the rotary and love to see people doing them.

       I want basically the TTC engine on av gas at 350 to 400 hp with maybe 2 ms3pro computers I am not sure yet there, I am watching what everyone's doing to reliably control fuel and spark and keeping up on the newsletter, that is if I don't get kicked off. Lol. I know I stirred the pot a little there.
Thanks, Jacob Sturgis

Car gas is a dollar a gallon lower cost and you will be running 10 to 12 gallons an hour.
One of the reasons I don''t fly my C182 anymore it cost about $500 or more to fill it up.
It only has 50 hours on a reman with a 2000 hour TBO.

Paul Lamar


The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want
off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you. ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.