12
Mark Steitle prematurity died a few years ago of cancer so
he won't mind me publishing his private message.
I flew in Marks airplane.
Here is the first indication I got for serious problems
with Tracy's gear box.
I eventually made it known. When and how I don't remember
but with a bit of research I can find out.
I did not want to bad mouth Tracy too much in those days.
So I have been trying to get people to fix things ever
since.
The coupling is no big deal. My latest design is very easy to do.
The coupling I designed for the 650 HP TTC is working fine.
Every time somebody or anybody designs something new there will be
problems.
Just a fact of life.
Paul Lamar
********************************************************************
Quote:
> Mark Steitle 2 msdstx@gmail.com <mailto:msdstx@gmail.com>
>
> Paul,
>
> The next time I have my gearbox apart I think I will add the second
> pin on the sun gear as you have shown.
>
> Yes, I recall the discussions on the torsional damper. Its a miracle
> it works at all.
>
> In fairness to Tracy, I think my cracked flex plate may have been
> caused by excessive run-out of the flex plate. It may have been
> damaged in shipment as it was attached to the engine which was
> strapped to a pallet. The new one is near perfect and shows no signs
> of cracking.
>
> Thanks, Mark
>
>
> On Sat, May 25, 2013 at 5:28 PM, rotaryeng <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>
> wrote:
>
> Tracy thinks he is too smart to be on this newsletter.
>
> We disused the weak pins on the input gear years ago. Also the rubber
> bushings in the flex plate were extensively discussed. They don't
> work as one might think. If you totally enclose a rubber bushing as
> Tracy has done it no it longer operates as rubber. It acts as a
> solid. Rubber is no more compressible than hydraulic fluid.
>
> That was mentioned too. If I send him email he ignores me.
>
> The problem with the 1/4 bolts derives from the lack of a torsional
> damper.
>
> Paul
>
>
>
>
> On 05/25/2013 12:50 PM, Mark Steitle wrote:
>
>
> Paul,
>
>
> I don't want this becoming "public knowledge" as we may have
> insurance people monitoring our posts and this could result in an
> increase, or worse case, unavailability of insurance on our a/c. So,
> please keep this post private.
>
> Over the past year, or so, I have experienced persistent oil leaks
> around the webs of my RD2-C box. Tracy commented that he had that
> same problem on a box and he recommended using some RTV in the
> threaded holes that were leaking. These are the 1/4-20 holes that
> the ring gear attaches through from the inside. Well, I took Tracy's
> advice and put RTV over the bolt holes. After a few applications of
> RTV, some of them stopped leaking, but others persistently kept
> leaking, although at a reduced rate.
>
> After thinking about the possible causes for this problem, I decided
> to tear the box down and inspect it from the inside. Well, what I
> found was startling. I found that seven (7) of the eight (8) 1/4-20
> bolts holding the ring gear to the casting were broken. Only one
> bolt was still in tact, and it was loose. After discussing this with
> Tracy, we agreed to drill and tap them to 5/16-20 which I did. I
> have only flown it once since the repair, but you can bet that I will
> be watching for oil leaks in this area from now on. Tracy stated
> that this is the first failure of this nature that he is aware.
>
> This is the fourth failure related to the psru that I have
> experienced. First, the smoking rivets on the flex plate adapter
> (Rivets worked loose - replaced them with 1/4-28 NAS close-tolerance
> bolts). Second, broken pin holding the sun gear to the input shaft
> (Tracy reworked it with a larger pin). Third, discovered cracks in
> the flex plate (Replaced with new flex plate & inspect often). And
> fourth, seven broken bolts on the ring gear. I am fortunate that none
> of these failures happened over inhospitable terrain. I inspect
> things fanatically and I am on the lookout for a more robust psru.
>
> So, this explains my question regarding the design limits on your
> design. I was hoping that you would tell me that it was designed to
> handle 500 hp, or something way above where I operate. I know that
> we need to strive to keep things as light as possible, but these
> failures are telling me that the box isn't up to the task.
>
> In all fairness, I think most of these problems are a result of
> rough-running during the tuning phase of my development. As you may
> remember, I've had lots of problems with mis-firing and rough running
> from the very beginning. I've got it running pretty good now, but
> the tuning still isn't perfect.
>
> Mark S.
>
************************************************
End quote.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Please add your questions or comments at the end of the thread.
Not the beginning.
I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not
be forwarded.
My ISP changed the rules.
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want
off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you. ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2017 All world wide rights reserved.