Subject: NTSB Report on Turbine failure 12 e
From: paul lamar
Date: 3/16/2018, 5:50 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



      12 e

      Paul, et al:

       From the NTSB
 report [WPR16LA088]:

      The pilot reported that
 he initially purchased the engine in 1999
      from Atkins Rotary,
 located in Eatonville, Washington, and that
      there were no historical
 records available for the engine. The
      pilot subsequently
 installed the turbocharger to the engine, with
      its first flight being
 in 2003.


      This is the interesting
 read from Hartzell:

 https://dms.ntsb.gov/pubdms/search/document.cfm?docID=450749&docketID=59730&mkey=92906

      -----

      It appears that he
 exceeded the EIT (Exhaust Inlet Temp) of
      1650F. He had an EGT set
 to warn if the Exhaust temps got to 1600F.

      Not being a
 turbo-charged engine operator, and knowing that this
      ATP was attempting to
 turbo normalize for 5000 MSL = SL, my
      question is, is it this
 easy to get into over-speed/over-temp
      conditions?

      Regards,
      Steve Thompson

      Tom Parke's engine is a
 3 rotor. That is a lot of hot exhaust gas.
      With a rotary it is wise
 to use a very large turbo as a given amount
      of hot exhaust gas will
 do less damage to the turbine. We use a
 large GT 40
      on the two rotor. Tom's
 is an older turbo charger as well. I would not
      be surprised
      if the turbine was not
 made from the best material now available.

      Tom also had a temp
 exhaust gas sensor but for some reason he did
 not see
      the warning.

      The turbine might have
 been damaged earlier and Tom did not notice it.

      Paul Lamar


 ------------------------------------------------
      Putting the material
 aside the turbine was made of there are two
 features
      of this installation
 that contributed to the turbine failure.

      The exhaust manifold was
 insulated to a degree by the sheet metal
 shroud.
      Removing that would cool
 the exhaust manifold to some degree.

      The turbo bearing was
 not water cooled. That is a common option
      that cools the turbine
 as well as the bearings.

      Both of these features
 led to a higher exhaust gas temperature
      impacting the turbine.
 It was only necessary to lower the temperature
      by 200 F. Despite the
 higher temperature it lived for ten years.

      I don't know what
 material the turbine was made from but the GT40
      turbo charger we use on
 the TTC is Inconel and the bearing housing
      is water cooled.


      Paul Lamar

      One of the water
 injection companies had a controller that could
 use EGT as
      an input that would
 solve this over temp problem.

      Murry Rozansky

 Paul and everyone,
 1650°F really isn't that high for a
 rotary exhaust gas temp. In a
 turbocharged version I would go so far
 as to consider it common. If
 that's to much for the turbine he would
 be forced to change to one of
 the Inconel or ceramic turbines. On the
 aircraft dyno Steve Beckham's
 latest stocker based P-port version
 would regularly see 1600. If you are
 at or near the ragged edge on any
 temperature issue with the rotary it
 would be wise to always default to the
 highest temperature resistant
 materials possible. Otherwise a few
 moments of mis-adjusted  mixture are
 going to cause damage.
 Bill Jepson

 Also just cool the exhaust manifold a
 little bit.

 Paul Lamar

Paul,
The temperature emitted from the exhaust port can be a killer for manifolds and turbine housings.
There are many variables that affect the temperature when the exhaust port opens but the main ones are:
1.- Ignition timing.
2.- AFR Mixture.
3.- And excessive port timing.


Note also that the internet "safe" mixtures and timing tend to aggravate/increase the temp at exhaust opening.

See 2 attachments.
Examine the red trace on the top right hand side at the vertical EO (exhaust opening) temperature.
One port opens at 1790C and the other at 1460C because the timing and burn rates differ.
The 1790C is the Internet "safe" settings (rich and retarded) and the second one is 1460C, it is optimized from AFR and timing combustion tests.

The detonation protection of rich mixtures and retarded ignition become a problem that has to be considered.

Turbine engines use similar but some what cooler temp limits.
800C take off.
927C never exceed.

Barry Bordes


 ------------------------------------------------------------------
Please  add your questions or comments  at the end of the thread.
Not the beginning.

I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be forwarded.
My ISP changed the rules.

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off
the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.  ACRE NL web
site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2018 All world wide rights reserved.