Subject: Gill aircraft batteries 12 b10
From: paul lamar
Date: 4/7/2018, 10:18 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink



    12 b 10

    I have a Gill  G-35 in the C182

    I took it out and checked the battery voltage. It was down below 4.5
    volts.

    Aircraft Spruce wants $231 dollars for a new one.

    The acid level was a little below the top of the plates.

    I added a little water to each cell.

    I hooked up the battery charger and very little current flowed. I
    left it charging for 18 hours. Voltage is now over 12 volts and
    charging current is 10 amps.

    I was blown away. That battery sat around for years.

    I'll learn more when I start the engine with it.


    Paul Lamar

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------






    Well I hooked everything up including my 200 amp battery charger. It
    puts out 200 amp to aid in starting so it claims. It works on the
    TTC engine.

    In this case the O-470 engine turned over very slowly while the pre
    oiler was running. The Gill measured over 12 volts just before I
    tried to turn the engine over.

    No question of starting.

    It could be a lead acid battery that measures the correct voltage
    will not put   out the current. I don't know of this and never heard
     about it.

    Looks like I will need to buy a 12 volt battery from Walmart and see
    how that does. The prop rotation was so slow I could have turned it
    by hand.

    After this was all over I checked the Gill battery again and it was
    over 12 Volts. I am a bit mystified.

    Paul Lamar


    My Gill did the same thing, showed over 12 volts but failed on
    delivering any amps, I used to have to hand prop the Pacer, once you
    replace it your worries will go away. I also bought an el cheapo
    cigarette lighter volt/ammeter on Amazon to see how the new battery
    does, and it confirmed no voltage regulator issues and normal
    current draw for everything except the landing light on my Pacer, so
    there's a wiring issue on that circuit that I will fix when I next
    have time


    Alex Molteno

    Paul,

    I’ve found that my deep cycle trolling motor batteries would only
    last about two years.

    I also discovered that if I use a small charger called a “Battery
    Minder” the interval would increase to about six years. It will
    usually charge a battery back to 12 V within 24 hours if everything
    is healthy. At that time it starts blinking showing that it is using
    a pulse charge that supposedly destroys the sulfurdatian on the
    plates. It was on special for about $39 at Northern Tool? Works
    great for me. Barry Bordes

    I have frequently seen batteries that will display their appropriate
     resting Voltage level, but failed to produce their rated amp hours.
     This usually first manifests by slow starting.  For 12 V batteries,
    the local auto parts place can easily test this function.

    I have used the batteryminder device for over 10 years, which seems
    to add at least one or two years to the life of aircraft batteries.

    Scott Gettings



    My inlaw put  30 AH Li-ion battery into his Toyota mini VAN. Weights
    less than three pounds. It has build in safety to prevent damage
    from full discharge.

    In my mind much cheaper and safer than a old lead acid battery.

    Henry Nee

    We had something like that in the TTC for awhile and then it shorted
    I think. Little tiny thing.  Dan is a electric fan. He has a Tesla.

    We were using my 200 amp battery charger to get it started. That
    worked for a couple of months. Then for some strange reason the
    engine turned over but it would not start. Turned out the Li-ion
    shorted and dragged down the 200 amp charger voltage so the Motec
    would not work any more.

    Kind of opposite to a sulfated lead acid battery.

    Took us a couple of weeks to figure that out. Took out the Li ion
    and put the lead acid back in. Now it is starting  again.

    They are a bit weird and unpredictable :-)

    BTW if your battery gets warm when you charge it that is a clue that
    it is sulfated and you need the Harbor Freight charger.

    Paul Lamar


    Paul, and group Two battery items. First, a lead acid battery will
    warm any time you charge it. In good shape it will warm less, but
    that alone isn't an indication of sulfation.  It can also be an
    indication that you are charging the battery to fast. Kawasaki
    motorcycles devotes some time to battery maintenance in all their
    technical training classes. Yuasa sends them the information.

    Slower is always better when it comes to charging. The Viking
    charger Paul mentions is excellent, as is the "Battery Tender" which
    is sold at Walmart for about the same price. Both have a float mode
    that put a minimum maintance charge on battery while drawing
    miliamps. Occasional use machines like planes or motorcycles can be
    left hooked up and will always be ready when you want to start them.



    Second, beware of the Li-ion battery for aircraft. It is enticing
    since it is so much liter and smaller. However recently we had a
    program at the Livermore CA EAA chapter 663. Since the chapter is in
    the shadow of Laurence Livermore Labs they have a high percentage of
    highly tech-savvy members. One invited a pioneer in the Li-ion
    battery field to do a talk for one of the meetings. His comment, "I
    would never run a Li-ion battery in my own plane."


    The reasons are that if the battery ever internally shorts, which is
    the primary means of failure in these batteries they will catch fire
    and release a VERY TOXIC gas. If  you have the resources of Boeing
    you can build a successful containment so the plane won't be harmed.
    In a small scale single battery use you could do it too, but you
    would lose all weight advantages you used the battery for in the
    first place. He also commented that this could happen with the
    battery at rest while minimally discharging.


    The technology has improved enough that it is now fairly rare for
    one to just fire up, but it still can and does sometimes happen. If
    you decide the risk is acceptable the best thing you can do is to
    keep the charge above 30% at all times with 30-90% being ideal. He
    gave us the quick lodown on the reason the Samsung Note 7's were
    catching fire , He said that after reviewing the specs he would have
    predicted it. He also said Apple bought their batteries from one of
    the best, read safest, manufacturers although he uses an android
    phone. All just offered as cautionary information not as absolutes.

    Bill Jepson

    An aviation supplier down here in South Africa was selling a Battery
    Minder charger/maintainer and I purchased one. However it had a note
    stating that it was not suitable for aircraft batteries. I notice on
    the Battery Minder website that they do make an aviation specific
    one ($240!) and that normal chargers will damage aviation batteries.
    They actually have some "technical jargon" as to why. Not being an
    expert in the electronics field, does this make sense or is it just a
    case of "bulldust baffles brains"?

    Pierluigi Ferro


    Pier (if I may), I don't have any idea why the charger wouldn't
    work. Note that the product I mentioned is a "BATTERY TENDER" not a
    battery minder. I don't know if they are the same product. The Viking
    from Harbor freight would also be good. I note that there is a
    different version of the Viking suggested for Li-ion batteries, but
    not for AGM or other versions of lead acid batteries. The arguement
    sounds like baloney to me. Just be sure the charger doesn't charge at
    more than about 2 amps and you should be fine. Bill Jepson

    We have two people that have tested the Harbor Freight Viking on
    aircraft batteries. Me and the Kitplanes guy. It worked for both of
    us. You are on your own with other brands.

    Paul Lamar


   I'm going to weigh in on this battery stuff. And I am addressing
   Lead Acid batteries, no other (e.g., NiCad, etc.).

   The design of systems with a battery and an alternator|generator
   is for the battery to "balance" the system. In general, the lower
   the charge in the battery, the more the current generation system
   can push (alternator or generator controlled by a Voltage
   Regulator). The voltage regulator is sensing for the voltage to
   hit (specified limit) of, say 14.2 volts for a "12" volt system.

   Once the battery charge comes up close to the target output
   voltage of the regulator -- if you have an AMP meter showing
   charge/discharge, you will see the current flow start to tail off
   to about 2-6 amps.

   Now, when you start an engine and that battery has to put out,
   say, 80 Amps to spin that engine, and you pull the charge level
   down to where it would only measure, say 10V, a car or truck
   charging system would immediately pump 30-40 Amps at that battery
   trying to pull the voltage back to the target voltage (14.2V).

   The battery will heat up because of the drain (current flow with
   some resistance and we have W=I**2 * R - Watts = Current squared
   * Resistance). Now we are causing the flow in the opposite
   direction (charging it back up) and that same formula is used
   again. So that battery is going to heat up.

   Where this gets ugly is in places where the ambient temp is 95F
   in the shade or better. That battery will get too hot. This is
   why I couldn't keep a battery in my cars in the Dallas TX area
   for more than 2.5 years before having to change them out. The
   Heat there plus being inside the engine compartment basically
   kills the battery.

   Now for charging systems: 2Amp "trickle" chargers work fine for
   holding Lead Acid batteries. You could probably get away with 6Amps.

   Motorcycle batteries are another problem. Small engines that do
   not use electric starters, are running a charging system to
   operate the lights. Yamaha DT series bikes back in the late 60s
   and into the 70s would blow the head lamp if the tail lamp burned
   out because the small battery did not have enough load for the
   system to keep that system from going to about 18V. The
   headlights were not designed for that.

   With starters, the batteries have to be larger and have a larger
   amp capacity to turn the engine. Same charging system as I recall
   (been gone from motorcycle mechanics and electricals for 20 years
   now).

   All of that to get to this: I call excessive semi-solid male
   bovine exhaust on this Aviation battery charging stuff.

   That Lead Acid battery has no idea if you are going to use it for
   running a trolling motor, or operating a flying saucer. The rules
   of physics are the same. V=IR, I=V/R, R=V/I -- Ohms law for DC
   (where I=current/amperage, V=voltage, R=resistance).

   I'll go back to watching and learning about the squish flow and
   flame fronts. I'm still trying to get my head around the pressure
   points.

   Regards,
   Steve Thompson




The  Lithium battery I am thinking is  LiFePO
_4  . Instead of older Li-ion battery of 3.7V, it has a 3.2V norminal voltage instead. So 4 cells in series makes up a 12.8V system. Charge voltage is 3.6V, so a four cell, in series battery may be charged at a maximum of 14.4V, very compariable to the 12V system we have in a vehicle.I think the battery can be discharged to 2.5V, or 10V without damage.

The battery does not catch fire, even when shot with a nail and sorted out. It does give out smoke. It is known that internal short will not cause fire for this battery.

One last defense is a battery management chip to prevent the cells from over discharge so it will last a very long time. And yes, it can operate pretty good even in colder climate.

LiFePO
_4   is very different from the typical Li-ion battery that we use in the computers, or even Tesla's cell. It is newer and I don't think Boeing's 787 is designed with these safer battery. I believe Boeing's 787 uses older, not so safe, 3.7V Li-ion battery.

Here is a link to some information on the battery.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate_battery

Link to a youtube video on what happens when it is shorted.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMARDvMz62A

By the way, this is now widely available in China for electric vehicle use due to its safety margin.

Henry Nee

------------------------------------------------------------------
Please  add your questions or comments  at the end of the thread. Not the beginning.

I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be forwarded. My ISP changed the rules.

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.

ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube  http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas or PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2018 All world wide rights reserved.