Subject: You tube video 12 c
From: paul lamar
Date: 7/27/2018, 3:20 PM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


         12 c
         How to Build a 650HP 250 pound Wankel Aircraft Engine

         https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=csbHS94qO6w

         I notice people are having trouble looking at this video.

         My fault but the trick is.... hit the stop button when a new screen appears.
         Then after you have read the screen hit the start button. Do this for each screen.
         The screens are just pictures and not video. If you know how to do screen
         captures that would be useful.

         Paul Lamar



         Hey, Paul


               I have a few questions and one concern, as you know I have been
    researching and seriously looking into running a rotary on our rv6 but have some
    concerns, the TTC has made a huge statement but in reality it's more of a race car
    engine running on methanol, than a viable aircraft engine being that its running on
    methanol and has aluminum housings.


                So far from my research nobody recommends the aluminum housings for
    street use or any type of regular use or anything besides racing they say they will
    not last, unless there is someone that makes one that will work for street use that I
    dont know about, which I hope they do, I know rb doesn't recomend theres. so assuming
    we can find aluminum housings or maybe make aluminum housing with a steel insert?
    What is a realistic reliable horsepower a turbo p port could make on av gas reliably,
    example what do you think would be the max cruise horsepower you could run at all day
    long reliably.


                Then we have weight if you dont mind me asking because I am trying to add
    all the weights to see if its possible for my instal is that 250 lbs including gear
    box and turbo and what is the weight of the entire engine package weight with
    coolant, cooling system and oil system with oil, the engine I would be running is
    also already dry sumped and p- port, but as of now with the stock housings it's way
    too heavy!!! I cant believe how heavy that little motor is with those iron housings
    it's a huge difference. Its currently running on a motec M400 but I am not a huge fan
    I think they are hard to work with, not very intuitive, so I'll have to look into
    that too. So that's kind of where I am at I do have access to some amazing designer
    engineers with a awesome cnc machine shop and manufacturing connections. I know it
    will be tough and expensive but I would only do it if I can get the weight cut down
    reliably, turbocharged  and constant speed  prop so probably going to have to go
    electric there, we fly at lots of different altitudes and dont like to give anything
    up climb, cruise, glide ratio, ect. I would love your input and thoughts on the
    actual installed powerplant weights wet and horsepower possible with what I am trying
    to do and thoughts on the housings.


              The one thing I really worry about on your video and site is I notice
    multiple times talking about just using a blow off valve to regulate boost which
    worked fine for what you were doing but I believe a properly sized wastegate will be
    much better for the job, it's more controllable and easier to dial in altitude
    compensation and on a aircraft relieving pressure on the compressor side would really
    risk over speeding the turbo at high boost and high altitude, specially with no
    exhaust relief at all. I found that out the hard way my blow off was stuck partially
    open and I overspend the turbo and grenaded it. I know that worked for the TTC
    situation but dont think that would be a good solution for something other than a
    exhibition aircraft. Just my opinion or way of thinking not trying to knock you or
    anything you have done, you obviously are the go to guy for these motor which is why
    I am here.


         Thanks, Jacob

    The TTC gear box is about 40  pounds. The cooling system parts are about 20 pounds.
    One gallon
    of water is 8  pounds.


    Two piece end housings will live as long as caste iron end housings
    or longer. No reason why not. Here are some pictures and drawings. A couple of OZ outfits
    are making them.

    With high boost and just a blow off valve you can control power with the throttle alone.
    A computer controlled waste gate is not needed. It is needed in a car where the load
    is a function of throttle opening and  RPM and load. In an aircraft there is a fixed
    relation between HP
    and prop RPM. See the graph. In other words at any prop  RPM there is a known load
    and HP.

    So you set the power by the prop RPM you want. There will be a delay and you may have to
    readjust the throttle until the boost and the  turbo spools up and establishes an
    equilibrium
    with a steady prop RPM. At full throttle the prop tips hit the sonic wall. When that
    happens
    more power will not result in more prop RPM or more thrust.

    In fact you could be applying
    more power but it is absorbed by useless vortices's off the prop tips. And that is
    where the blow
    off valve should be set. The 182 plot shows this.

    In cars and particularly in road racing you need instant throttle response. Not so in
    aircraft.

    Paul Lamar


    Thanks for the response Paul,


    That machine work is beautiful on those housings! I was not worried about spool up or regulating boost with the blow off valve, I was worried about overspeeding the turbo because if you are not relieving exhaust drive pressure to manage boost and you are using the compressor side to regulate boost, the turbo has to spin at a much higher rpm to maintain the desired manifold pressure setting. If you were relieving pressure on the exhaust drive side with a properly sized wastegate the turbo just wouldn't have to spin as fast to make the desired manifold pressure setting, and would be operating in a more efficient area of the compressor map as well. Specially at high altitude I would worry about overspeeding the turbo. By the way I am speaking more in regards to the average experimental aircraft installation than the TTC.


             Also do you think basically the TTC engine on av gas would be reliable at 350 to 400 hp take off power and 225 to 300 hp cruise. That's the power goals,  I am hoping are realistic and more importantly reliable.


    Thank you very much,  Jacob Sturges

Most waste gates on the market are not near large enough to make a difference.
Even the largest  blow off valve springs  must be beefed up.

We used a very large turbo. GT40 It would be difficult to over speed it I suspect.
It did not have to spin very high to get the boost. Big is good as a given amount of heat
will affect the larger blade strength  less. This turbo would have to get to 80 inches of HG  before
it got near  125,000 RPM.

Max turbo  RPM is a function of actual strength of the blades.
Larger blades run cooler. That is why I recommend using large turbo's for aircraft engines.
Turbo RPM acceleration is not a factor in aircraft. It is very important in cars. In F1 they
use an electric motor to accelerate the turbo.

Over speed is probably possible I would guess. Garret turbo's have the capability to use turbo
tachometers. If I were worried about turbo over speeding I would install a turbo tact.

On av gas you would need an intercooler on the intake system. Not easy to duct.
I notice Rotax has just come out with a 135 HP turbo version with an intercooler
for 35K $. A one rotor turbo would last 10 times as long and would be way
more reliable at the same or more HP.

It will be interesting  to see how someone installs that :-)

Paul Lamar


------------------------------------------------------------------
Please  add your questions or comments  at the end of the thread. Not the beginning.

I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be published. My ISP changed the rules.

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.

ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
YouTube  Key word "PaulLamar2".
Copyright 1998-2018 All world wide rights reserved.