12 c
****************************************************************************
-----Original Message----- From: Rotary Engine
[
mailto:rotaryeng@earthlink.net] Sent: 11 March, 2010 11:55 AM To:
AAA Put this in the To box Subject: lean burn
I had the OBD II on the Honda and I saw a lot of situations where it
went way lean. The gov only cares about the arbitrary driving cycle
and they don't peer over the shoulders of the company EFI
programmers. From a software point of view it is easy to detect the
silly driving cycle.
The nox v BSFC situation was discussed in Bruce Briggs book War
against the Automobile.
Paul Lamar
What is not real world about turbo compound. CW made thousands of
R3350 TCs. A Super Connie could stay aloft for 24 hours. Actually the
exhaust valve was the Achilles heel. The head would come off and take
out the turbine. Rotary no problem no exhaust valves.
Paul Lamar
"As to the Honda leaning out during off-cycle driving, I don't know
what your car does, but such a calibration would be highly illegal
and I doubt that Honda, or anyone else, uses it."
Csaba Csere
Hey Csaba, Looks like VW was caught doing just exactly that. See
the attached jpg.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the
list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2015 All world wide rights reserved.
***********************************************************************
This is an old message. I told the news letter it was possible to
detect the calfornia smog test and modify the mixtrure controled by
an EFI to reduce NOX at the expense of higher fuel burn.
Csaba Csere editor of Car & Driver poo pood the idea as not
possible. Then a year later, or so, VW got cought doing it.
Now there is a netflix video about it called "Dirty Money".
Paul Lamar
The 49 states model Hondas allowed lean burn... The throttle would
have to be held constant for about two seconds for the program to be
enabled.
Lean Burn AFR's would be about 18.... Engineered by scientists not
California politicians.
Search Honda lean burn.
Barry Bordes
You can get the mixture data in real time using an OBD II scanner.
The irony is California has done away with that tail pipe test used on the
VW diesels.
They now use an OBD II scanner to check what is going on.
My 2004 RX8 just passed the OBD II scanner test.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
I didn't say that lean burn was impossible, but I did say that it was
illegal since all-to my knowledge, all gasoline-burning cars in the US use
3-way catalysts that don't work with lean mixtures. Now another person has
suggested that Honda has figured out a way to run lean under certain
conditions. If they can do it and stay within he emissions parameters that
would help efficiency a bit and Honda is a very clever company.
By the way, I haven't been following this recent VW case closely, but the
last I saw was that Germany's Transport Ministry did not confirm this recent
report about VW cheating on gasoline emissions testing. Do you have any
newer info?
Csaba Csere
Quote:" The War Against the Automobile
B. Bruce-Briggs Dutton, 1977
"Let us now turn to the real costs of the automobile, beginning with one of the most
exaggerated and misunderstood-emissions.
The discovery of the air-pollution effects of auto exhaust emissions is one of the
great ironies and minor tragedies of history.
Remember that the introduction of the automobile was supposed to alleviate the
pollution problem caused by the effluents of draft animals and coal-burning trains.
For fifty years the world labored under the delusion that vehicular air pollution was
a thing of the past. Toward the middle of the century, however, people in Los Angeles
began to notice something in the air, which later came to be labeled "smog,"
presumably a combination of smoke and fog. But the scientist Dr. Arlie Haagen-Smit
learned that it really resulted from the action of sunlight and heat upon
hydrocarbons and oxides of nitrogen in the air, particularly those emitted from
automobile exhausts. The phenomenon is properly called "photochemical smog." The
process that results in smog is incredibly complicated and by no means perfectly
understood, but its outlines are not disputed. Gasoline consists of complex compounds
of carbon and hydrogen. In an automobile engine these are combined with air,"
No hydrocarbons no smog.
No NOX bad gas mileage.
"So improving combustion by detailed modifications of major design changes reduces
both, but the rub is the oxides of nitrogen. Decreasing the hydrocarbons increases
the NOx' Look at the chart (Figure 2). An auto engine runs on a mixture of gasoline
and air-the normal operating range is from 13.5 to 16.5 parts air to one part
gasoline. Within normal operating ranges, hydrocarbons and CO can be reduced by
increasing the ratio of air to fuel but NOx goes up. This is simple to understand.
Reducing HC and CO requires better combustion to obtain more combination with oxygen,
producing halmless H2O and CO2.
But better combustion also results in more combination of nitrogen with oxygen,
producing NOx' The nature of operation of the Otto-type internal-combustion engine,
used in almost all cars in the world, precludes eliminating both hydrocarbons and NOx.
Now the reader may reasonably ask this question: If the smog is caused by the
combination of NOx and hydrocarbons, why is it necessary to get rid of both of them?
That is an excellent ques- "
" The father of smog, Professor Haagen-Smit, said "the Muskie bilI passed last
December [1970] without Congress understanding that emissions in 1970 vehicles had
already been controlled 70 to 80 percent." He described the EPA air quality standards
for hydrocarbons as "absurd."
End of BB quote.
The world is just now beginning to understand this.
The main problem is there are not enough engineers or scientist in the congress or
the senate.
The people of the united states are paying a huge price for a needless waste of gasoline.
Paul Lamar
------------------------------------------------------------------
Please add your questions or comments at the end of the thread. Not the
beginning.
I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be
published. My ISP changed the rules.
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the
list PLEASE let me know and I will remove you.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net YouTube Key word "PaulLamar2".
Keep clicking this as Youtube will try to divert you to advertising.
Copyright 1998-2018 All world wide rights reserved.