13 a Hi Paul,
I'm an engineering student who is also working at a start-up
aerospace company. I would like to learn more about rotary engines.
Please point me in the right direction.
Thanks, Eric Rinell
There are two clues to high deficiency of cars and prop driven
aircraft, They are BSFC and engine power to weight ratio. The Wankel
can excel at both. We just set a prop driven aircraft world record
on time to climb to 10,000 feet which largely depends on engine
power to weight ratio.
The world F1 road racing organization demands turbo compound which
raises the over all efficiency of the piston engine from 35% to 50%.
Turbo compound can do even better with the Wankel.
It is time for the world to pull their head out of their smart phones
(asses) and recognize these facts.
Paul Lamar
Turbo-compounding has issues in real-world applications. Back around
2008, my customer launched an HD engine with turbo-compound.
Customer a major international engine supplier with state-of-the-art
engineering and development resources. I had a few test engines with
the turbo compound, but didn't see it in the later MY engines. Not
sure why it was removed, but I suspect it reduced the efficiency of
the after treatment (emissions control) system.
Hakan Uras
I don't see how it could do that except perhaps lowering the
temperature of the exhaust gases. Detroit Diesel AKA Mercedes Bence
sold many DD15 truck diesel turbo compound.
NOX reduction is still refused all over the world except in the USA.
Reducing NOX has a terrible affect on Diesel MPG and Germany refuses
to do it. Diesel run wide open throttle full lean high NOX all the
time and the power is controlled by how much fuel is injected until
you get black smoke.
I have been in many large cities around the world (35 countries) and
I don't see anything like the smog we had in LA back in the 60's.
I have never found any data that NOX, in typical atmospheric
concentrations, affects the health of people. If you have some
please upload it.
Paul Lamar
DDC/MB phased out turbocompounding in 2015 or so. If you look on
DDC's website, there is no more mention of it.
Turbocompounding causes issues with emissions control because all
catalysts need heat to function. Below a certain temp threshold,
catalysts don't do anything. Once they get to temp, they are
virtually 100% efficient. Adding a 2nd turbine downstream of the
turbo reduces exhaust temp, so it will reduce the efficacy of the
emissions control system. Turbocompound does work to improve fuel
economy. That's been proven repeatedly. You are correct that it
would be especially effective on a Wankel since the exhaust temps
are higher then on a piston engine, so the enthalphy of the exhaust
is higher (e.g. there's more energy to drive the turbo-compound).
Europe, Germany included, has regulated NOx for years. If you buy a
new diesel vehicle in Germany, it will be equipped with a NOx
aftertreatment system.
Hakan Uras
Perhaps VW passes the German NOX test the same way they did it in
California :-)
https://www.dw.com/en/angela-merkel-aims-to-ward-off-diesel-car-ban-in-germany/a-45978487
" Angela Merkel aims to ward off diesel car ban in Germany
Angela Merkel has pledged to introduce legislation to stop
"disproportionate" bans on diesel cars. The chancellor was speaking
ahead of the state election in Hesse, where her CDU is desperate for
a good showing.German Chancellor Angela Merkel has warned it would
be "disproportionate" to ban diesel cars in cities where limits on
nitrogen emissions are only being marginally exceeded.
Speaking to reporters in Berlin on Sunday evening, Merkel pledged to
introduce legislation that would allow car owners to continue
driving older diesel vehicles.
Many drivers have been left outraged as a number of major German
cities — including Frankfurt, Berlin and Stuttgart — have threatened
to limit or ban older diesel engines from their roads
<
https://www.dw.com/en/court-orders-partial-ban-for-diesel-cars-in-berlin/a-45813568."
Merkel said diesel car owners should not bear the costs
<
https://www.dw.com/en/opinion-diesel-drivers-are-voters-too/a-45727046
of having their older diesel engines retrofitted with catalytic
converters, which would reduce the amount of nitrogen emissions cars
produce.
Diesel car emissions have raised nitrogen levels above the permitted
level of 50 milligrams per cubic meter in several cities across
Germany.
However, Merkel's proposed legislation would enshrine in law that
diesel car bans are disproportionate in cities where there are only
marginal excess nitrogen levels. In Frankfurt, for example, the
nitrogen level stands at 57 micrograms
<
https://www.dw.com/en/frankfurt-must-ban-old-diesel-cars-court-rules/a-45373435
thanks largely to a series of environmental measures, such as the
introduction of cleaner buses.
End quote.
Maybe pig piss is the answer :-)
Paul Lamar
Apparently not for turbo-props and jet engines. There has been a
problem with JET-A contaminated with DEF. For some reason turbine
engines do not like the stuff.
https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/business-aviation/2018-09-21/faa-issues-saib-jet-def-contamination-incident
https://www.sealaviation.com/aviation-news.html Covers similar
item with different info.
I have driven, commercially, Semis before DEF came out. And the
computer controlled direct injection is just wonderful. Driving
up a mountain scaled out at 72,000, all I could see coming out
the stacks was a light gray exhaust. Far cry from what it used to
be with older trucks where it was just black. I also noticed that
the engine, at idle, was rather quiet!
The latest straight truck I drove with DEF was interesting. Same
light gray exhaust. And the engine and its exhaust was rather
quiet (output under the bed as opposed to vertical stack).
I'd rather have a turbo-compound engine because in my mind,
burning less fuel for the same horse power is a lot better than
blowing DEF into the catalytic converter.
BTW -- I have also been in cities and towns Germany, Austria and
Switzerland driving cars. They do not hold a candle to the smog
in LA back in 1979-83 when I was there. And most cities in the
USofA that I have frequented do not have the smog problems they
had in the 60s-80s -- they have EPA problems in my not so humble
opinion.
Regards,
Steve Thompson
------------------------------------------------------------------
Please add your questions or comments at the end of the thread. Not the beginning.
I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be published. My
ISP changed the rules.
The Rotary Engine free News Letter. Powered by Linux. If you want off the list PLEASE
let me know and I will remove you.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
YouTube Key word "PaulLamar2". Keep clicking
this as Youtube will try to divert you to advertising.
Copyright 1998-2018 All world wide rights reserved.