Subject: Stunning engine weight to airframe weight. 12 b
From: paul lamar
Date: 1/5/2019, 10:04 AM
To: A10-Me-Earthlink


    12 b

    Back in 1948 they discussed the engine weight as a factor
    in airframe rate in the turbo compound SAE paper.

    They felt it was 3 or 4 pounds of airframe weight for every
    pound of engine weight.

    Since we got 650 HP out of the time to climb Mazda Wankel
    250 pound engine (including gear box)  it allowed use to have a total empty aircraft
    weight
    of 1000 pounds. That is a four to one ratio.

    Of course we set the official world time to climb to 10,000 feet record.

    No one will ever beat that unless they use a turbo Wankel engine like we did.
    A turbo compound Wankel engine would set a world record for low fuel burn
    per HP aka BSFC.

    No 650 HP piston engine comes anywhere near 250 pounds.

    Paul Lamar


    I agree those numbers are amazing and the rotary engine is very impressive but I also think that we should realize even though the rare bears record was retired due to the fai changing to weight classes it still did the same feat faster at 91.9 seconds with a 1940s piston engine. I am not trying to belittle what you guys accomplished with the rotary engine, I am extremely impressed and intrigued, I just think it should be noted that it is indeed possible for a piston engine to have the required power to weight ratio,  we should also note that in exhibition form like the TTC engine, piston engines routinely have a better power to weight ratio.


    One of the offroad sand cars we run, we having been running the crap out of it for 4 years now with no tear down or inspection at over 1430 horsepower on e85 and with both turbos all accessories ready to drop in minus the intercooler and radiator it weighed 469 pounds.  Thats a power to weight ratio of 3.04 compared to the TTC of 2.6 so slightly better than the TTC, thats just my own experience, there are tons of lsx boat engines ran for extended periods of time as well with much more power.


    Again not knocking anything just showing that while a rotary with aluminum housings has a amazing power to weight ratio that in racing or all out performance the modern piston engine has a better power to weight ratio so its definitely possible that the record could be beat with something other than a rotary engine, hypothetically speaking.


    I personally while love seeing what the TTC did and love all out max effort performance builds, am very interested on what that engine could do reliably on 100LL. If it could have a 2000 hour tbo at 350 to 400 hp take off 325 hp cruise or continuous power that would be a real winner and awesome engine for a broad spectrum of aircraft.


    Thanks, Jacob Sturges

Our 250 pound weight included the gear box.
What does your gear box weigh? Without the gear box our engine was 200 pounds.
In that case the ratio was  3.25 to one. We had no intercooler.

Did you every run it for over two minute at 1430 HP?  I suspect it would blow up because of
the reverse bending loads on the crank shaft pins. The Wankel has no reverse bending loads
on the e-shaft. We ran our engine time after time at over two minutes.
Many drag racing drag piston engines run for only 5 seconds or less.
Drag racing Wankel's are putting out well over a 1000 HP.

We set the record at only 60 inches of manifold pressure because the prop blades
were not wide enough for 83 inches and 650 HP. My guess it was only 500 HP or so.

Here is the Motec recording of the record run. With wider blades we could easily
beat the Rare Bear record at 90 seconds. Do you have any recordings of your engine
parameters?

BTW the Rare Bear engine was the same block used in the Turbo Compound R3350.
The power to weight ratio of this engine in the Super Connie was 1 to 1.

Paul Lamar

------------------------------------------------------------------
Please  add your questions or comments  at the end of the thread.
Not the beginning.

I am going to enforce that rule. If people don't do that it will not be published.
My ISP changed the rules.

The Rotary Engine free News Letter. 750 subscribers world wide.
Powered by Linux. If you want off the list PLEASE let me know and I will remove  you.

ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
YouTube  Key word "PaulLamar2". Keep clicking
this as Youtube will try to divert you to advertising.
Copyright 1998-2019 All world wide rights reserved.