Here is a rough draft of the Abstract of my AIAA
paper on turbo compound sthat I will present at the
Jan 07 meeting of the AIAA in Reno Nevada.
Please read it over and make any and all comments.
I need to submit it by the 22th tommorrow.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.
Turbo compound Wankel rotary engine.
Paul Lamar
Rotary Engine Newsletter
Santa Paula California
rotaryeng@earthlink.net
www.rotaryeng.net
TURBO COMPOUNDING THE ROTARY
A turbo-compound engine
collects all of the exhaust gasses and runs them through a turbine, with all
of the power generated going back into the crankshaft and ultimately to the
propeller thereby recovering some of the waste heat in the exhaust.
Ref 1.
1954 SAE Transactions. Development of the R3350 Turbo
Compound Engine.
Besides the economic advantage of turbo compounding an engine there
are other consideration.
Short range also cuts into long trip times and limits your weather
options making the airplane less safe.
Having the range to turn back has saved my life
more than once when on a long cross country's over remote areas of Canada,
Alaska and Baja. A high performance airplane with a small thin wing has a
limited volume for fuel. Such air cooled piston engine airplanes may need
to stop every 400 or 500 miles for fuel.
Turbo compounding also improves the power to weight ratio of an
engine by roughly 20%. Ref 1.
Allison built a V12 turbo compound engine during World War II in an
attempt to recover some of the waste energy resulted in a turbo-compound
configuration. Ref 2 It was identified as the V1710-E22. Work began in
1944 and continued until 1946. It was sponsored
by the US government but canceled with the advent of the turbine
engine. Apparently it was the first turbo-compound engine.
The V1710-E22 had a military rating of 2320 hp, and a War
Emergency Rating with water/alcohol injection of 3090 hp.
With a compression ratio of 6:1 it achieved a 19% improvment
in the BSFC. It never flew. The normal supercharged Allison V12
generated 2000 take off HP and 2500 HP War Emergency Rating.
Ref 2
Vee's For Victory by Daniel D. Whitney. Schiffer Miltary History
1998 ISBN 0-7643-0561-1
The most widely used turbo-compound engine was a version of the air-cooled,
18-cylinder, two-row radial Curtiss Wright R3350-TC. Ref (1) Used in
many airliners and several miltary aircraft. Thousands were built. This
engine had three turbines, each fed by 6 cylinders, that were geared
to the crankshaft.
The normal supercharged version produced 2700 hp and weighed 2850 lbs.
The BSFC was as low as .37 at sea level and .33 at 30,000 feet with
a compression ratio of 7.2:1. The turbo-compounded version produced
3500 hp and weighed 3440 lb resulting in a power to weight ratio of over
unity. The worlds record prior to the Rutan Voyager for un-refueled
distance was held by a P2V that flew from Australia to Ohio. Super G
Lockheed Constelations with this engine were able to fly non-stop LA
to London over the pole in the 1950's.
Ref 1a. "Lockheed Constellation" by Stringfellow &
Bowers Motorbooks ISBN 0-87938-379
The Achilles heel of this engine proved over time to be the failure
of the exhaust valves when the exhaust gas pressure was 25% higher
than the intake pressure. Much of the developement effort was expending
on improvements in exhaust valve durabilty.
Another protoype turbo-compound engine is the Napier Nomad, which was
built in England. It was a 12-cylinder, horizontally opposed, liquid cooled,
valve-less, 2-stroke cycle Diesel engine with a 3-stage turbine. It
reached flight test but not production. BSFC was .345 (shaft HP) at
11,000 feet and a compression ratio of 8.25. Ref 3
Ref 3 A history of Aircraft Piston Engines by Herchel Smith
Sunflower University Press Corrected editon 1986 ISBN 0-89745-079-5
NACA sponsored several reports on turbo compound engines.
One of which used a dynamometer data to gather data.
This test program indicated a BSFC of .323 at 10,000 feet.
14% better at 10,000 feet and 21% better at 30,000 feet.
Ref 4
NACA REPORT No. 822 1944
CALCULATIONS OF ECONOMY OF 18-CYLINDER RADIAL AIRCRAFT ENGINE
WITH EXHAUST-GAS TURBINE GEARED TO THE CRANKSHAFT
By RICHARD W. HANNUM and RICARD H. ZIMMERMAN
The Wankel rotary engine is a very mechanically robust engine that
tolerates high boost pressures. There are no cyclical reversing
stresses in the three major moving parts that lead to fatique failure
in the light weight piston engine. Consequently the power to weight
ratio of the current Mazda RX8 Wankel rotary engine is comparable to an
air cooled aircraft engine at 240 HP and 190 pounds less the weight
of the required PSRU.
The compression ratio is enherently low limited to about 10:1 due the
neccesitty of locating the combustion chamber in the rotor. The
combustion chamber surface to volume ratio is high affecting the
efficiecny of combustion but adding to the ability of the engine
to survive high power to displacement ratios.
The Wankel rotary has no exhaust valves. Porting is done by the rotor
as it orbits the inside of the rotor housing. The Wankel rotary
has approxmately three times the net available kenetic energy in the
exhaust as compared to a piston engine. Two thirds of the total kinetic
energy in the exhaust of a pistone engine is disapated by the exhaust
valves. Ref 1
The high level of kinetic energy in the Mazda Wankel rotary engine
exhaust has been known for 30 years. Anybody that has been present at
race where a Mazda Wankel rotary powered race car operated a muffler
can appreicate the tremendous kinetic energy in the exhaust.
There is always as much or more potential HP in the exhaust as there
is available from the output shaft. (Ref 6) The more you boost it the
more HP is available to boost it. This is an exponential effect so
the real HP limit is detonation, durability and structural strength
of the core engine. Turbo charged Mazda 2.6 liter two rotor engines
have been boosted to 800 HP for racing purposes using alcahol
and nitrous oxide. The Wankel rotary appears to be an ideal gas
generator for a turbine engine.
Ref 6 Rotary Engine. by Kenichi Yamamoto.
Sankaido Company Ltd. 1981 In English. No ISBN number.
BUILDING A TURBO COMPOUND WANKEL ROTARY ENGINE.
I had an idea on how to implement a turbo compound arrangement using a
ball traction drive gear box from a Paxton Centrifugal supercharger.
The HP, gear reduction and RPM is about right for connection a turbine
and feeding the power back into the engine instead of removing it.
Hopefully we will get 20% more power with no more fuel and no additional
load on the engine cooling system.
My compound setup for the rotary would use one turbo charger turbine
feeding power into the eccentric shaft and an turbo charger centrifugal
blower using modern aerodynamics from a stock Mazda turbocharger.
We will start with a turbine reduction gear ratio that peaks the torque
feed back to what the engine will tolerate at sea level and at an
e-shaft RPM of 7500. That e-shaft RPM assumes you are using a PSRU with
a 2.85:1 reduction ratio and a maximum prop RPM of 2630.
The historical evidence suggest we will eventually get more than a 20%
efficiency improvement with a turbo compound rotary.
We are now building a traction drive device to extract the excess HP from
a stock turbo charger. Input speed RPM can be up to 100,000 RPM and output
RPM will be one tenth of that. The power from the traction drive output shaft
will be transfered to the e-shaft of the rotary by a V-Ribbed belt to absorb
the torsional vibrations from the rotary engine. We hope to recover at least
50 HP from the waste heat in the rotary exhaust improving the BSFC from
the current .47 to .38 at cruise altitude. The range of any airplane using
this engine will increase by 25%. We hope to test the engine soon on a dyno
Stratified Charge Rotary Engine Critical Technology Enablement Volume II
NASA Contractor Report 189106
APPENDIX C DATE 10/04/91
Turboaachinery Systea Analysis For stratified Charqe Rotary Engine.
Sunstrand Aerospace
C.E. Irion and R.E. Mount
Rotary Power International, Inc.
Wood-Ridge, New Jersey